Marduk Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> you have the opinion of one person

Actually no ... if you read what I wrote you'll see others have done similar work on the site. And the people who BUILT the site said the same thing.


> is that the best you can do Kat

I told you that the Dresden Codex which was written very near to Chichen Itza ****SAYS**** that Venus was important to them for predicting events and it ****SHOWS***** how they themselves sighted Venus... if the word of the people themselves who built the thing isn't good enough for you then I don't know what is!

You have a belief system here Marduk ... nothing I say will change it ...


> i'm not impressed but as you say i will keep m,y
> sumerians seeing as so far no one has debunked
> anything i've said

We've debunked EVERYTHING you've said!


> we've had mummies sprayed down with tobacco to
> keep bugs off when it was a molecular sample from
> inside hair follicles

Had you followed the link I provided you would have seen a post discussing plants native that containe nicotine from Africa to Asia .. I even pointed it out to you.


> we've had Sumerians in england to get Tin

You are misrepresenting what Warwick said .. he merely disagreed you with that Titicaca was the best source of tin.

> sumerians in Afghanistan to get tin

Yes ... Sumerians in Afghanistan to get tin... you think this is more far fetched that them going to South America for it?!?!?! When I pointed out to you that your very description of the region that they said their tin came from matched Afganistan? I also provided you with an academic reference SHOWING the tin came from Afganistan.


> we've had "all civilisations founded in river
> valleys

Most of them were ... for good reasons .. transportation ... trade ... etc etc...


> we've had reed boats shown are not long-range
> ocean going vessels when i already stated that its
> possible to get there by island hopping across the
> pacific

You've got some huge gaps there ... island hopping won't get you all the way.



> quetzlcoatl wearing a green boiler suit

As drawn by the people themselves from the Borgia Codex.... and of course its not a boiler suit... stop putting your impressions on these people.



> we've had why would anyone value a coca bush.

No ... I said why would it be the ONLY thing they took back when South America is so rich in foodstuffs and other plants.


> we've had dragon boats to the same design which
> must be just a coincedence

Actually I said there are only so many ways to tie reeds together to make a boat.

You also had Bernard tell you that Q. as a white man from the east is NOT a Meso legend... we've debunked everything you said and showed the flaws in your arguments ... but I suspect you'll just keep repeating them .... shame that.

And please don't suggest that I "can't get my head around" anything again .... and don't misrepresent what I state in my arguments again. I don't do it to you.



Kat

Ma'at Moderator

Founder and Director of The Hall of Ma'at

Contributing author to Archaeological Fantasies:
How pseudoarchaeology misrepresents the past and misleads the public
"If you panic, you're lost" -- W. T. 'Watertight' Southard