Re: Two Thesies

Home

Discussion Forums

Papers

Authors

Web Links

May 5, 2024, 8:46 pm UTC

In: The Hall of Maat > Ancient History - Ancient History and Archaeology > Topic

Goto: Forum List • Create A New Profile • Log In

Ancient History • Ancient Egypt • Laboratory • Humanities • Apocalypse • Paper Lens • Coffee Shop
Exhibitions, Conferences, Lectures, Journals • Alternative Geometry and Numerology

Claire

August 22, 2001 03:18PM

<HTML>Ishmael

>>All I need to show is that a relationship exists and that the odds against its having emerged due to chance are astronomical. For that, all I need is statistical evidence producing probabilities.

I don't think you can prove this statisically - you can't prove it was deliberate in this way. Co-factors such as topography also need to be considered. I think that statisical analysis is a red herring here.

Actually I think that RB does it right. He spotted a possible relationship (his hypothesis) and then searched for evidence that the AE's would have held special significance to Orions Belt, or that they had an 'as above so below' type mentality. He decided that both were justified and therefore an actual relationship was likely. That's it. An exact duplication may lend weight to this theory, but that's all.

This doesn't affect your contention that the MTs were laid out according to some ground plan to mirror Orions Belt - I am not qualified to judge that at all - I'm just saying that in my view statisical analysis is not a subsitute for bypassing the Egyptology here. I think that it's relevant.

Claire</HTML>

Reply Quote

Subject	Author	Posted
Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 22, 2001 10:29AM
Re: Two Thesies	Jason	August 22, 2001 11:17AM
Re: Two Thesies	Katherine Reece	August 22, 2001 11:23AM
Re: Two Thesies	Jason	August 22, 2001 11:31AM
Re: Two Thesies	Claire	August 22, 2001 11:27AM
Re: Two Thesies	Jason	August 22, 2001 11:31AM
Re: Two Thesies	Claire	August 22, 2001 01:49PM
Re: Two Thesies	Katherine Reece	August 22, 2001 02:04PM
Re: Two Thesies	Claire	August 22, 2001 02:15PM
Re: Two Thesies	Katherine Reece	August 22, 2001 02:22PM
Statistical Analysis	Claire	August 22, 2001 02:41PM
Re: Statistical Analysis	Don Holeman	August 22, 2001 07:07PM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 22, 2001 02:48PM
Re: Two Thesies	Claire	August 22, 2001 03:18PM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 23, 2001 08:27AM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 22, 2001 02:16PM
Re: Two Thesies	Katherine Reece	August 22, 2001 02:20PM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 23, 2001 10:37AM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 22, 2001 02:13PM
Re: Two Thesies	Claire	August 22, 2001 02:17PM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 22, 2001 02:51PM
Re: Two Thesies	Katherine Reece	August 22, 2001 02:58PM
n/t	ISHMAEL	August 22, 2001 02:59PM
Re: Two Thesies	Derek Barnett	August 22, 2001 03:12PM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 23, 2001 08:45AM
Double standard?	Derek Barnett	August 23, 2001 12:08PM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 22, 2001 01:23PM
Re: Two Thesies	Katherine Reece	August 22, 2001 01:39PM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 22, 2001 01:56PM
Re: Two Thesies	Claire	August 22, 2001 01:58PM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 22, 2001 02:58PM
Re: Two Thesies	Claire	August 22, 2001 03:03PM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 23, 2001 08:30AM
Re: Two Thesies	Martin Stower	August 23, 2001 10:30AM
Re: Two Thesies	John Wall	August 23, 2001 05:15PM
Re: Two Thesies	John Wall	August 22, 2001 07:19PM
Re: Two Thesies	Mikey Brass	August 22, 2001 07:24PM
Re: Two Thesies	John Wall	August 23, 2001 05:15PM
Re: Two Thesies	Dave Moore	August 24, 2001 03:20AM
Re: Two Thesies	John Wall	August 24, 2001 05:28AM
Re: Two Thesies	Dave Moore	August 24, 2001 05:48AM
Re: Two Thesies	John Wall	August 24, 2001 05:51AM
Re: Two Thesies	Dave Moore	August 23, 2001 02:55AM
Re: Two Thesies	John Wall	August 23, 2001 06:02AM
Re: Two Thesies	ISHMAEL	August 23, 2001 08:46AM
Re: Two Thesies	John Wall	August 23, 2001 05:17PM
Re: Two Thesies	Stephen Tonkin	August 23, 2001 01:19AM
Re: Two Thesies	John Wall	August 23, 2001 06:02AM
Re: Two Theses	Stephen Tonkin	August 23, 2001 01:19AM
Re: Two Theses	John Wall	August 23, 2001 05:18PM

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login