Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 12, 2024, 1:15 pm UTC    
February 11, 2008 07:05PM
DDeden Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------

> I've reconstructed the Ancient Malay, based on
> Austronesian, Indonesian, Philippine comparisons.
> Doesn't it appear that Malay should be in the
> neighborhood of Oscan and Lycia? I think so.

I don't think so at all. First of all, your reconstruction of "Ancient Malay" is impressionistic and demonstrably incorrect. Forms like "triga" or "palmpa" are not justified by any data I know of. Secondly, Austronesian is a vast language family, much larger than IE, and it isn't enough to compare word-lists in a few selected languages to reconstruct anything. Thirdly, there's no need to reinvent the wheel. The Proto-AN numerals have already been reconstructed:

1. *esa
2. *duSa
3. *telu
4. *Sepat
5. *lima
6. *enem
7. *pitu
8. *walu
9. *siwa
10.*sapuluq

Vague and superficial similarities like Malay "empat" vs. Oscan "petora" are deceptive, as usual. Oscan is an Italic language in which the sound *kW (preserved as "qu" in Latin), changed into /p/ (cf. Latin "quinque" but Oscan "pompe"). The Oscan numeral '4' developed regularly out of Proto-IE *kwetwores (is THAT similar to Proto-AN *Sepat?).
Subject Author Posted

AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 01, 2008 12:39AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Byrd February 01, 2008 11:52AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Lee February 01, 2008 11:55AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Warwick L Nixon February 01, 2008 02:37PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 01, 2008 08:21PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

cladking February 01, 2008 09:05PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 02, 2008 12:02AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Warwick L Nixon February 02, 2008 12:54AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 02, 2008 03:12AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Warwick L Nixon February 02, 2008 01:47PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 02, 2008 02:49PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Warwick L Nixon February 02, 2008 02:55PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 02, 2008 03:06PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Warwick L Nixon February 02, 2008 03:31PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Byrd February 02, 2008 01:26AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 02, 2008 04:40AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Piotr Gasiorowski February 02, 2008 01:02PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Hermione February 02, 2008 01:16PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 02, 2008 08:34PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Hermione February 03, 2008 04:33AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 03, 2008 09:19PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 03, 2008 09:20PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Piotr Gasiorowski February 03, 2008 04:03PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 03, 2008 09:44PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Hermione February 04, 2008 04:11AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Piotr Gasiorowski February 04, 2008 02:28PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 04, 2008 08:14PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 09, 2008 11:55PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Hermione February 10, 2008 04:48AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Hermione February 10, 2008 04:52AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 10, 2008 09:48PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Piotr Gasiorowski February 11, 2008 07:05PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 12, 2008 01:52AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 13, 2008 04:46AM

**Thread closed**

Hermione February 14, 2008 04:25AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Byrd February 04, 2008 04:18PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 04, 2008 08:15PM

Aker, Akeru, Akhet

DDeden February 02, 2008 04:52AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Byrd February 03, 2008 03:35AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 03, 2008 10:29PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Byrd February 03, 2008 11:46PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 04, 2008 08:17PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Doug Weller February 04, 2008 09:47AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Byrd February 10, 2008 12:44PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Byrd February 12, 2008 02:19AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

DDeden February 12, 2008 03:12AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Byrd February 12, 2008 09:17PM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Byrd February 04, 2008 09:17AM

Re: AE words: technical origins, water, stonework

Doug Weller February 05, 2008 03:57AM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.