MJ Thomas Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Hello Anthony,
>
> I wrote, 'That is your opinion, and I respect
> that.'
>
> You reply, 'It is a logical conclusion, not an
> opinion. An opinion is an uninformed, often
> irrational, judgment. This is none of the
> above.'
>
> Hmmm. Opinion: A personal belief or judgment that
> is not founded on proof or certainty.
>
> So, in effect you are saying that your logical
> conclusion is as good as proof or certainty?
> I beg to differ.
>

I did not say that, ergo, your interpretation of my words is not the same thing as my words, and I deny your interpretation's validity.



>
> You write, 'My questioning has led me to the
> undeniable conclusion that Khufu was indeed
> interred in his tomb at Giza... in the sarcophagus
> contained in the room colloquially known as the
> King's Chamber.'
>
> Yet you haven't read Smyth or J & M Edgar!


I don't really care about people's opinions.



> I fail to see how you can arrive at a sensible
> conclusion when you have yet to examine all the
> evidence available.


What evidence do you know I have not examined?



> You would benefit from reading of, for example,
> Edgar's exploits in the Well Shaft.
>


I have.



>
> You write, 'No, I don't think there were more than
> three. I concur with M&R on that.'
>
> Given the number of mistakes in their work, I
> would treat their opinions with caution, if I were
> you.

I concur with their logical argument, not their opinions.


> And as you don't 'think' there was more than three
> blocks stored in the Gallery, I presume you are
> still open to the hypothesis that there were
> more.
>

Of course not. It's illogical. Read M&R and you'll see why.

Anthony

You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him think.