Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 4, 2024, 8:05 pm UTC    
August 01, 2007 09:18AM
These two paragraphs appear together. I can't imagine they were actually written at the same sitting, though:

Quote


As is well-known, there is a patent lack of contemporary inscriptions to be found on the 4th Dynasty pyramids at Giza.[1] In contrast, the last pyramid of the 5th Dynasty and most pyramids of the 6th Dynasty have their inner walls filled with religious texts which, collectively, are known as the Pyramid Texts. Today most Egyptologists, except perhaps the very inflexible, agree that the ideologies expressed Pyramid Texts can be project, albeit with some degree of caution, back to the 4th Dynasty.

The main thrust of the Pyramid Texts is the afterlife of the dead king. There are many passages that tell how the king unites with the sun-god Re in the eastern horizon at dawn and, seemingly coming from an earlier doctrine, where we are unequivocally informed that his afterlife destiny is among the stars.



If there is no written evidence of an earlier doctrine, how can we be unequivocally informed, specifically with regards to the Dynasty IV pyramids at Giza, that the earlier doctrine included an afterlife in the stars?

I'm not arguing that there wasn't a belief system in Egypt that may well have included this belief earlier than the first appearance of the Pyramid Texts, but it is deplorable methodology to take a plausible speculation like that and make it the foundation of further theories... which is what the OCT does at every turn.

The fact that lots of people believe it is true does not actually make it so, and you can't proceed as if it were. That's the methodology of Creationism... not Egyptology.

Anthony

You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him think.
Subject Author Posted

'The Circumpolar Constellations in Ancient Egypt' by Bauval

Richard Fusniak August 01, 2007 04:08AM

Re: 'The Circumpolar Constellations in Ancient Egypt' by Bauval

Dave L August 01, 2007 04:31AM

Re: 'The Circumpolar Constellations in Ancient Egypt' by Bauval

Morph August 01, 2007 05:58AM

Re: 'The Circumpolar Constellations in Ancient Egypt' by Bauval

Warwick L Nixon August 01, 2007 08:52AM

Interesting contradiction....

Anthony August 01, 2007 09:18AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Warwick L Nixon August 01, 2007 09:23AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Dave L August 01, 2007 09:27AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Anthony August 01, 2007 09:31AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Dave L August 01, 2007 09:48AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Anthony August 01, 2007 10:26AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Warwick L Nixon August 01, 2007 09:56AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Chris Tedder August 01, 2007 12:11PM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Warwick L Nixon August 01, 2007 12:25PM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Anthony August 01, 2007 02:04PM

Re: Interesting contradiction.... PS

Anthony August 01, 2007 05:01PM

Re: Interesting contradiction.... PS

Chris Tedder August 03, 2007 12:17PM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Chris Tedder August 03, 2007 11:53AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Joe_S August 01, 2007 03:40PM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Warwick L Nixon August 02, 2007 10:11AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Chris Tedder August 02, 2007 04:32PM

Re: Interesting Theosophy....

Morph August 03, 2007 04:43AM

Re: Interesting Theosophy....

Morph August 03, 2007 05:07AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Joe_S August 03, 2007 03:04PM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Chris Tedder August 03, 2007 04:38PM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Greg Reeder August 03, 2007 04:39PM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Hermione August 04, 2007 06:31AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Chris Tedder August 04, 2007 07:13AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Hermione August 04, 2007 01:41PM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Chris Tedder August 04, 2007 02:08PM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Hermione August 05, 2007 04:06AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Chris Tedder August 05, 2007 05:04AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Ritva Kurittu August 05, 2007 07:39AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Ritva Kurittu August 05, 2007 07:34AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Hermione August 05, 2007 07:56AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Ritva Kurittu August 05, 2007 09:34AM

Re: Interesting contradiction....

Dave L August 02, 2007 11:21AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login