Re: Ishmael

Home

Discussion Forums

Papers

Authors

Web Links

May 6, 2024, 8:40 pm UTC

In: The Hall of Maat > Ancient History - Ancient History and Archaeology > Topic

Goto: Forum List • Create A New Profile • Log In

Ancient History • Ancient Egypt • Laboratory • Humanities • Apocalypse • Paper Lens • Coffee Shop
Exhibitions, Conferences, Lectures, Journals • Alternative Geometry and Numerology

Claire

August 08, 2001 11:27AM

<HTML>Ishmael

Technically we're on the same side here ~lol~

While you're on the subject could you help me out on something? One of the arguments I have come across is that no other momument has been dated using geology - that it is not a recognised method of dating anything. (well anything man made I guess). What do you think of that line?

>>Your fist statement, that the importance of an artifact to a particular dicipline governs which discipline has jurisdiction over its meaning, is nonsensical - as I am certain you know. Diciplinary relivance canot be used to determine who "trumps" whom.

So how would you determine it? (this isn't rhetorical!) Do you think that geology trumps archaeology per se, or specially on this occasion, or do you think that some criteria can be used to decide what would win out of geology and archaeology should they come into conflict :-)

[when my little brother was a toddler and he went through the question asking stage he was constantly asking similar questions ~lol~ like; what would win out of a bee and a wasp? what would win out of a lion and a tiger?, what would win out of a frog and a toad? As in - should they come to fight ~lol~ always things that were similar but not quite the same. It lasted about 2 years (well probably not, but that's the way I remember it) - funny to think that I'm still asking similar questions now ~lol~]

Thanks

Claire</HTML>

Reply Quote

Subject	Author	Posted
Reasons for a new path	IAB	August 06, 2001 02:08PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Derek Barnett	August 06, 2001 02:18PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	IAB	August 06, 2001 02:24PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Derek Barnett	August 06, 2001 02:43PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	IAB	August 07, 2001 10:29AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	JoeRoyle	August 07, 2001 10:47AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	IAB	August 07, 2001 11:06AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	ISHMAEL	August 07, 2001 09:02AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Katherine Reece	August 07, 2001 09:08AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	JoeRoyle	August 07, 2001 09:54AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Claire	August 07, 2001 10:16AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	JoeRoyle	August 07, 2001 10:29AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Claire	August 07, 2001 11:20AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Garrett Fagan	August 07, 2001 01:20PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Claire	August 07, 2001 02:14PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Garrett Fagan	August 07, 2001 03:18PM
Re: Thanks	Claire	August 07, 2001 04:11PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	ISHMAEL	August 08, 2001 09:29AM
Re: Ishmael	Claire	August 08, 2001 11:27AM
Re: Ishmael	ISHMAEL	August 09, 2001 08:01AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Litz	August 07, 2001 03:24PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Claire	August 07, 2001 04:19PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Greg Reeder	August 06, 2001 03:47PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Graham'O	August 06, 2001 04:04PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Joanne	August 06, 2001 06:13PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Greg Reeder	August 06, 2001 10:57PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Don Barone	August 07, 2001 05:36AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Greg Reeder	August 07, 2001 10:24AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Joanne	August 07, 2001 07:36AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Garrett Fagan	August 07, 2001 09:38AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Katherine Reece	August 07, 2001 10:15AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Joanne	August 07, 2001 02:19PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	IAB	August 07, 2001 02:28PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Garrett Fagan	August 07, 2001 03:26PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Joanne	August 07, 2001 05:48PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	IAB	August 07, 2001 10:41AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Garrett Fagan	August 07, 2001 12:45PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	IAB	August 07, 2001 01:00PM
Re: Reasons for a new path	IAB	August 07, 2001 10:37AM
Well Ian	D.Przezdziecki	August 06, 2001 09:22PM
Re: Well Ian	Mattcarps	August 07, 2001 05:04AM
Re: Well Ian	IAB	August 07, 2001 10:53AM
Re: Well Ian	IAB	August 07, 2001 10:51AM
Re: Reasons for a new path	Greg Reeder	August 07, 2001 03:32PM

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login