Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 18, 2024, 7:18 am UTC    
March 16, 2010 04:47PM
Petrie set himself the task of proving or disproving Smyth's pi theory in which the shape of the Great Pyramid, the design of the King's Chamber, and the volume of the Coffer, were all said to be based on pi = 3.14159..
Petrie concluded that the pi ratio evident from the design was 22/7. The long walls of the King's Chamber have a length of 560 digits (20 royal cubits) and a perimeter of 1,760 digits in the pi ratio 22/7. (The height of the walls is 320 digits, made up of 5 very precise courses of granite blocks of 64 digits.) This mirrors the shape of the Great Pyramid on a scale of 1 digit to 1 royal cubit. The perimeter of the base of the pyramid is 1,760 royal cubits (4 x 440) which was interpreted as the circumference of a circle, and 1,760 divided by 2pi is 280 as the height of the pyramid, interpreted as the radius of the circle.
Petrie noted that the shape of the Coffer strongly bears out the pi theory. The internal area is equal to the area of a circle with a diameter of 2 1/2 royal cubits, and the volume is equal to a sphere with a diameter of 2 1/2 royal cubits - 'by the true contents this would need a cubit of 20.644, which is very close to the best determinations'
The internal diagonal is very close indeed to 4 royal cubits (112 digits). Some years ago I noticed that 112 x 2 1/2 = 280 as if the diagonal was a symbolic mulitiplier. It follows that a circle with a diameter of 280 royal cubits may have been seen as equal to the triangular cross-section of the Great Pyramid by using the pi ratio 22/7.
Smyth attributed the discovery of the proportions of the Coffer to the seventeenth century survey of Greaves. Smyth spotted the pi proportions of the King's Chamber, as far as I know.
The three professors named above had very different views about the Great Pyramid, but all measured the Coffer and came to the same conclusion about its shape. I note that it would have been possible to hollow out a hemisphere and measure its volume by filling with sand. Alternatively, as we know that AE could calculate the volume of a pyramid, and even had a formula for the volume of a truncated pyramid, then it may be that the volume of a sphere was considered as many needle shaped pyramids, rather like obelisks. ie the volume of a sphere is the same as a pyramid in which the base of the pyramid is the surface area of the sphere and the height of the pyramid is the radius of a sphere.
Petrie noted that objects such as diorite bowls showed clear evidence of having been worked on a lathe, and yet no such device has been found. This did not stop Petrie from concluding that a lathe had been used. The Coffer was made from a single piece of granite - using a huge tubular drill according to Petrie. The technology of huge drills and precision lathes has not been substantiated by the discovery of the tools, but it would be ridiculous to argue that AE did not have such tools. Petrie did not assume that the Greeks were the first to discover pi, the volume of sphere, etc. He simply looked at the evidence and weighed it in the balance.
'Weighed in the balance and found wanting' is a popular phrase from the judgement of Belshazzar king of Babylon recorded in the Bible. Ideas flowed out of Egypt with the Israelites and others, including the idea of a soul of a person being weighed in the balance. Likewise, mathematical ideas may have come out of Egypt, or may have been discovered independently. There is no proof that the Babylonians were the first to divide the circle into 360 degrees. The idea may have come from Egypt, or may have been decided on independently. My hypothesis on the shape of the Bent Pyramid is based on dimensions in digits, and does not rely on pi ratio 22/7. Is it not true that the peoples of all nations had the ability to discover elementary geometry? Why should anyone argue that the Greeks and the Babylonians thought so very differently from the Ancient Egyptians?
Subject Author Posted

The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 10, 2010 06:21PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Don Barone February 10, 2010 06:39PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 14, 2010 03:26AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione February 11, 2010 04:46AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 27, 2010 05:26AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione February 27, 2010 09:04AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 28, 2010 03:42AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione February 28, 2010 05:35AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 28, 2010 08:53AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione February 28, 2010 10:12AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 28, 2010 02:49PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon February 28, 2010 03:13PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 28, 2010 04:27PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione February 28, 2010 05:00PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon February 28, 2010 05:01PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase February 28, 2010 05:28PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon February 28, 2010 05:34PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase February 28, 2010 06:03PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon February 28, 2010 07:11PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase March 01, 2010 04:00AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione February 28, 2010 04:38PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon February 28, 2010 02:14PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase February 28, 2010 03:16PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon February 28, 2010 03:23PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase February 28, 2010 03:32PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon February 28, 2010 03:59PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 28, 2010 03:55PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase February 28, 2010 04:08PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 28, 2010 05:52PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon February 28, 2010 07:14PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton March 01, 2010 02:02AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon March 01, 2010 12:15PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase March 02, 2010 09:29AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon March 02, 2010 11:15AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton March 02, 2010 11:48AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 02, 2010 12:39PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton March 03, 2010 11:56AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 03, 2010 01:22PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton March 05, 2010 02:57AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 05, 2010 04:24AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Dave Lightbody March 06, 2010 01:08PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 06, 2010 01:26PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Dave Lightbody March 06, 2010 01:53PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 06, 2010 05:41PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Dave Lightbody March 06, 2010 06:04PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 15, 2010 04:49AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Sirfiroth March 15, 2010 10:44PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

lobo-hotei March 16, 2010 07:07AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Sirfiroth March 16, 2010 11:51AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton March 16, 2010 04:47PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 17, 2010 11:33AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton March 17, 2010 02:00PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase March 17, 2010 05:32PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Jammer March 24, 2010 01:09PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 17, 2010 05:32PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon March 03, 2010 01:25PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton March 04, 2010 03:18AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 04, 2010 06:10AM

method 2

Warwick L Nixon March 04, 2010 01:57PM

Re: method 2

Mark Heaton March 04, 2010 02:50PM

Re: method 2

Warwick L Nixon March 04, 2010 03:20PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon March 04, 2010 12:06PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon March 02, 2010 02:23PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione February 28, 2010 04:53PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton February 28, 2010 03:36PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Warwick L Nixon February 28, 2010 04:05PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Hermione March 01, 2010 04:52AM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase February 11, 2010 01:15PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

Mark Heaton March 06, 2010 12:15PM

Re: The shape of the Bent Pyramid

GChase March 07, 2010 04:08AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login