Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 8, 2024, 5:57 pm UTC    
Lee
September 05, 2007 06:14PM

As I wrote, there is no reason to doubt the translation of the passage in question, and the editions of the Greek I have looked at do not indicate that there are major problems with the Greek text that could lead to differing translations of the same passage. That said, I think there are good reasons to doubt the existence of an Egyptian inscription of the form reported by Herodotus, although I don’t doubt that there could have been inscription on the exterior of the pyramid. My skepticism comes from the fact that in all of my reading of AE materials I have never come across an inscription of this sort, indicating “how much was spent on radishes and onions and garlic for the workmen,” or the equivalent. Such an inscription strikes me as entirely out of character for AE. The closest thing I can think I can think of are the temple inscriptions that indicate things such as “it’s doorway is electrum,” etc. but I don’t think the amount spent for the slaves is likely to get a mention in a royal text intended to glorify the king. I am one of those who thinks Herodotus should generally be given the benefit of the doubt, but the alleged content of this inscription makes my extremely dubious.

Lee
Subject Author Posted

New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Jon_B August 28, 2007 03:55PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

fmetrol August 28, 2007 04:28PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

MJ Thomas August 28, 2007 06:27PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Anthony August 29, 2007 01:26PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

MJ Thomas August 29, 2007 01:59PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Anthony August 29, 2007 07:25PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

MJ Thomas August 30, 2007 01:47AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Anthony August 31, 2007 01:51PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

MJ Thomas August 31, 2007 02:21PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

MJ Thomas August 29, 2007 02:16PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Anthony August 29, 2007 07:27PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

MJ Thomas August 30, 2007 02:31AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Hermione August 30, 2007 03:28AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Ritva Kurittu August 30, 2007 04:23AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

MJ Thomas August 30, 2007 09:20AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Ritva Kurittu August 30, 2007 01:57PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Anthony September 03, 2007 07:03AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Ritva Kurittu September 03, 2007 08:30AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Anthony September 03, 2007 10:04AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

MJ Thomas September 04, 2007 06:00AM

The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Anthony September 05, 2007 09:24AM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Hermione September 05, 2007 10:07AM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Anthony September 05, 2007 10:14AM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Hermione September 05, 2007 10:41AM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Anthony September 05, 2007 10:50AM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Hermione September 05, 2007 11:06AM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Warwick L Nixon September 05, 2007 12:10PM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Hermione September 05, 2007 12:38PM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Anthony September 05, 2007 01:16PM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Lee September 05, 2007 01:58PM

Thanks, Lee (n/t)

Hermione September 05, 2007 02:03PM

Thank you, Lee

Anthony September 05, 2007 02:04PM

Re: Thank you, Lee

MJ Thomas September 05, 2007 04:22PM

Re: Thank you, Lee

Anthony September 05, 2007 04:39PM

Re: Thank you, Lee

Tommi Huhtamaki September 05, 2007 04:51PM

The Priests of Khufu, as identified by Herodotus

Anthony September 05, 2007 05:25PM

Re: The Priests of Khufu, as identified by Herodotus

Hermione September 06, 2007 06:50AM

Re: Thank you, Lee

Hermione September 06, 2007 03:42AM

Re: Thank you, Lee

Anthony September 06, 2007 08:58AM

Re: Thank you, Lee

Hermione September 06, 2007 10:55AM

Final comments

Anthony September 06, 2007 01:49PM

Re: Final comments

MJ Thomas September 06, 2007 05:08PM

Re: Final comments

Anthony September 07, 2007 09:33AM

Re: Final comments

MJ Thomas September 07, 2007 07:54PM

Re: Final comments

Hermione September 07, 2007 09:59AM

Re: Final comments

MJ Thomas September 07, 2007 08:18PM

Re: Final comments

Hermione September 08, 2007 03:40AM

Re: Final comments

MJ Thomas September 08, 2007 06:59AM

Speculation as history

Anthony September 10, 2007 10:25AM

Re: Speculation as history

Hermione September 10, 2007 11:03AM

Re: Speculation as history

MJ Thomas September 13, 2007 04:57AM

Re: Speculation as history

Anthony September 13, 2007 06:30AM

Re: Speculation as history

Anthony September 13, 2007 06:39AM

Re: Speculation as history

Lee September 13, 2007 12:17PM

Re: Speculation as history

Anthony September 13, 2007 07:53PM

Re: Speculation as history

fmetrol September 13, 2007 08:51PM

Re: Speculation as history

Hermione September 14, 2007 08:22AM

Re: Speculation as history

MJ Thomas September 14, 2007 04:54PM

Re: Final comments

Hermione September 07, 2007 08:23AM

Re: Final comments

Anthony September 07, 2007 08:27AM

Re: Final comments

Hermione September 07, 2007 09:54AM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Anthony September 05, 2007 12:16PM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

Hermione September 05, 2007 01:59PM

Re: The credibility of Herodotus, vis a vis Egypt

fmetrol September 05, 2007 12:36PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Hermione September 05, 2007 09:46AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Anthony September 05, 2007 10:06AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Hermione September 05, 2007 10:33AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Ritva Kurittu August 29, 2007 02:41PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Lee September 05, 2007 06:14PM

Funerary inscriptions

Anthony September 05, 2007 07:53PM

Re: Funerary inscriptions

Hermione September 06, 2007 03:11AM

Re: Funerary inscriptions

Hermione September 06, 2007 07:39AM

Re: Funerary inscriptions

Anthony September 06, 2007 08:33AM

Re: Funerary inscriptions

Lee September 06, 2007 08:51AM

Re: Funerary inscriptions

Anthony September 06, 2007 09:09AM

Re: Funerary inscriptions

Hermione September 06, 2007 11:00AM

Re: Funerary inscriptions

Lee September 06, 2007 12:16PM

I agree

Anthony September 06, 2007 12:34PM

Re: Funerary inscriptions

Hermione September 06, 2007 12:42PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Hermione September 06, 2007 03:01AM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Kanga September 05, 2007 10:57PM

Re: New paper on Giza layout by Giulio Magli

Lee September 06, 2007 10:28AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login