From here [
www.skyandtelescope.com]
Quote
So why hasn't WASP-18b already gone "poof"? Hellier's team figures that the solar-type star (spectral type F6) is about a billion years old. Yet tidal theory argues that the big planet will edge close enough to be torn apart in well under a million years. As theorist Douglas Hamilton notes in an accompanying perspective, the odds of finding WASP-18b just before its swan song are akin to "drawing two consecutive red aces from a well-shuffled deck of cards."
Conceivably, observers were indeed very lucky to have discovered WASP-18b when they did. But if that's the case, then lots of other hot Jupiters, like one dubbed OGLE-TR-56b, should likewise be wrapping up their death marches — and they're not. Perhaps there's an undiscovered second planet in the mix whose gravitational tugs are preventing WASP-18b's demise. More likely, something's amiss with our understanding of how tidal energy dissipates within the star's interior. If it's a far more frictionless process than believed — say, by a factor of 1,000 — then the planet can hang in there for another billion years.
As Jammer says, things can appear to defy the laws of physics if we do not have (or understand) all the information of a system. For example, for years blackbody radiation defied the laws of classical themodynamics physics before the advent or understanding of quantum mechanics. Basically, the observed spectrum was a hump, but the theory predicted an exponential increase in emitted intensity with increasing frequency (See diagram below).Once QM was discovered, the observed blackbody spectrum was explained fully and agreed with theory.
Jonny
The path to good scholarship is paved with imagined patterns. - David M Raup
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 08/15/2011 05:14PM by Hermione.