they aren't points

they are cherry picked shots in the dark based upon your predetermined conclusion that the Utterances talk about geysers

"Do you even read my arguments? "

Posting a succession of lines from the Utterances out of context and saying..

it clearly must be referring to what you would like it to..

is not making an argument

Making an argument would entail you quoting the Glyph or glyphs in question and making a case for their being translated differently, thus allowing for your interpretations to 'hold water'.

you are asking this panel to completely disregard the body of Knowledge that is Egyptology..You claim to disregard ( ie not even bother to read), and even deny the existence of ,that body of knowledge on a constant basis.

You constantly state that the Concensus translation/interpretation of what the utterances are and say, does not make sense. That is because you are reading them out of context.

"You say that there is no mention of water crowns and boats that fly up and
alight; no mention of water in the Eye of Horus and no relationship between
this water and the greening of the horizon."

I have said no such thing

what I question is your literal interpretation

"You say that your powers of falsification
are superb"

that's not what I said at all.."because to my understanding..which has been subjected to far weightier personal standards of falsification than your own..the Utterances to NOT allude to any water Under pressure. "

IOW's where the interpretation or the translation is in question, I refer to my primers to see what the variables are..

I check all possible sopurces that reference the place name or divinity, or salient aspect of same

all this is tempered by an ever growing knowledge of the Pre Proto and Early Dynastic..along with that of the Old Kingdom.

The people, their beliefs, the rites associated with same,their infrastructure, their technology, their art and language, their funerary arrangements.

These are what you need to reference, to be able to falsify your theory.

It is not up to me or anyone else here to do so for you.


Warwick





" I have always found that the main obstacle to free
association on these boards is the broad
misconception that what we do not know is more
significant than what we do know."

Warwick L Nixon, March 8, 2019