Hans Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Hermione Wrote:
> -------------------------------------------------------
...
> > And yet he's [Scott Creighton] not open minded enough to properly
> > consider the evidence of the analysis of the
> > pattern of crew-marks in the relieving chambers
> > presented by Ann Macy Roth.
> >
> > Nor is he open minded enough to properly
> > investigate published evidence that could
> refute
> > the claims of Walter Allen's logbook.
>
Hans:
> As I noted above he lives in a world where if
> evidence questions his opinions it either is
> forged or doesn't exist. He's been on that endless
> pathway to know where for over a decade or so.
And - to pursue the point about evidence that Scott doesn't appear to have considered - what about the correspondence from Humphries Brewer's employer and colleagues on the Buda Pesth Chainbridge? Those letters shed important light on Brewer, and raise yet more questions over Walter Allen's logbook account ...
Hermione
Director/Moderator - The Hall of Ma'at
Rules and Guidelines
hallofmaatforum@proton.me