Hermione Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Hans Wrote:
> -------------------------------------------------------
>
> > ... anyone can deny
> > anything and if you are closed-minded enough
> one
> > can reject pretty much ever piece of evidence
> on
> > anything.
>
> The real problem with Scott's Creighton's approach
> to methodology and evidence is that he himself
> exhibits the very failings of which he accuses
> others.
>
> He denounces as "closed minded" those who question
> his conclusions.
>
> And yet he's not open minded enough to properly
> consider the evidence of the analysis of the
> pattern of crew-marks in the relieving chambers
> presented by Ann Macy Roth.
>
> Nor is he open minded enough to properly
> investigate published evidence that could refute
> the claims of Walter Allen's logbook.

As I noted above he lives in a world where if evidence questions his opinions it either is forged or doesn't exist. He's been on that endless pathway to know where for over a decade or so.