cladking Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> "Atum" was and then ceased to exist.
>
> But the Pyramids still existed and kings continued
> to die so the Pyramid Texts were redacted. Every
> place in the PT that "atum/. N" appeared it was
> removed and replaced by "osiris/ N". They were
> still in the process of editing "atum" out of the
> PT when the first copies from the 5th dynasty
> were written and these are the earliest version we
> have. "Atum has been almost completely eliminated
> in our available version but everywhere that
> "atum" must have physical properties like "weight"
> this word remains rather than having the word
> "osiris" substituted for it. In the longer run
> they even said "osiris tows the earth by means of
> balance" which obviously requires weight but by
> this time the writers couldn't really read the
> ancient writing either because the formatting for
> meaning in language had changed.

...do you have a link to a person who can actually read and understands the language that agrees with what you wrote above?

You mentioned 'ancient writing' I would remind you that you've never established that this actually existed. All you've ever done is state it as a claim. We look forward to your extensive publication where you lay out how everyone who can actually read AE is wrong and you are right.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/07/2019 09:04AM by Hans.