Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 6, 2024, 4:29 am UTC    
October 16, 2007 08:39PM
Hi Katherine
My bad. Simply jamming too much information into too few sentences. In fact I was thinking of "The Shipwrecked Sailor" and the talking snake who tells a tale about an object coming so close to the earth that it incinerated his family. I know I'm skipping passed many details, and I'm drawing on my memory from Budge's translation, which is of course inadequate for a thorough understanding of AE mythology. But,I've always felt that this was a fragment of a description of some celestial encounter. Maybe a comet that broke up before impacting with the earth. The Myth of Sekhmet iirc has that same almost cosmic element as Ra sends out his "eye" to destroy mankind.

As far as Atlantis goes. I remain absolutely neutral on it. Yes it was incorporated into Plato's writings and was little more than an aside in his work. What is it a couple of pages out of what over a thousand pages of philosophy? While everybody knows about Atlantis, how many people know about his "The Laws"? Darn few. However, to dismiss Atlantis because of a paucity of evidence is ridiculous in my opinion. For instance if we were to evaluate the impact of the Hittites on Levantine based on the number of times they're mentioned in the bible. We would say they had absolutely no impact at all since iirc the word "Hittite" is mentioned once and the plural "Hittites" is mentioned either once or twice and that's it. Based on that paucity of evidence we could dismiss the hittites as "mythological" or an insignificant tribe. Of course we know that the Hittites played more than a minor role in the middle east. But one thing that infuriates me with scholarship is if there's little or no mention of something then it's almost automatically categorized as a "myth" and forgotten about or dismissed.

As far as these videos go. I think they provide strong evidence that myths are based in reality. For instance the commentator on the rabbit video sounds like he has a strong southern accent. What are the main rabbit myths from the south? How about Brer Rabbit? How many brer rabbit tales are based on real life interaction with rabbits and other animals and people? I'll bet quite a few but they're all dismissed as "just so" stories.

Like I said the kid with the cobra reminds me of the story with Hercules strangling the snakes in his cradle. Looking at this video it makes me wonder if the Hercules myth is a fragment of somekind of child/snake interaction as is portrayed in the video.

Anyhow HTH.
Subject Author Posted

Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

Rick Baudé October 14, 2007 10:18PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

Anthony October 15, 2007 11:38AM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

Rick Baudé October 15, 2007 08:20PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

Katherine Griffis-Greenberg October 16, 2007 02:29PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

Rick Baudé October 16, 2007 08:39PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

rich October 16, 2007 10:53PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

Rick Baudé October 16, 2007 11:21PM

Is there a myth of Atlantis?

Doug Weller October 17, 2007 04:03AM

Re: Is there a myth of Atlantis?

Hermione October 17, 2007 04:20AM

Re: Is there a myth of Atlantis?

Doug Weller October 17, 2007 05:05AM

Re: Is there a myth of Atlantis?

Hermione October 17, 2007 06:21AM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

rich October 16, 2007 11:55PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

Katherine Griffis-Greenberg October 17, 2007 03:58AM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

rich October 17, 2007 12:17PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

Pete Clarke October 16, 2007 02:44PM

Excellent point

Anthony October 16, 2007 04:22PM

Re: Excellent point

Warwick L Nixon October 16, 2007 05:53PM

Re: Excellent point

Jammer October 17, 2007 12:40PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

cladking October 15, 2007 09:31PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

rich October 15, 2007 10:01PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

rich October 17, 2007 08:30AM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

rich October 17, 2007 09:33AM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

Byrd October 17, 2007 05:27PM

Re: Are myths based on reality? I'd say yes....

rich October 25, 2007 01:54PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login