Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 23, 2024, 12:46 am UTC    
October 09, 2001 01:34PM
<HTML>From the article...

"The food packets were mainly dropped in the central highlands and along the Pakistan border, both areas with suspected mines. We have to ask if the Americans are aware of the situation on the ground."

"suspected mines". Operative word: "suspected". Not guaranteed. Not documented. Only suspected.

This is armchair quarterbacking at its finest.

At WORST, there's probably a 50/50 chance that a foodpacket landed on a mine... that's if 50% of the land had mines under it.

Well, the way I see it, there's a 100% chance that these people are going to die WITHOUT the food and medicine.

Which would you rather us do? Let them die?

If it were my life, I'd be taking the 50/50 odds.

Again, stop complaining about imperfect methodology. You want perfection? Ask God to deliver the food. Until then, even the article clearly states that this is the "last resort" preferred by the aid workers... but they did NOT rule it out.

Why hold up America's efforts at humanitarianism as some kind of condemnation?

You people really just don't get reality, do you....

Anthony</HTML>
Subject Author Posted

Once more into the breach... attacks begin

Anthony October 07, 2001 12:09PM

Re: Once more into the breach... attacks begin

Deano October 07, 2001 12:52PM

Re: Once more into the breach... attacks begin

Anthony October 07, 2001 12:56PM

Re: Once more into the breach... attacks begin

William T. October 07, 2001 01:58PM

Re: Once more into the breach... attacks begin

John D. Miller October 07, 2001 02:08PM

Re: And your point was?

al-Urman October 07, 2001 03:35PM

Re: And your point was?

John D. Miller October 07, 2001 03:47PM

16 Hospitals hit

Anthony October 07, 2001 01:05PM

Re: 16 Hospitals hit

William T. October 07, 2001 01:53PM

Re: 16 Hospitals hit

Anthony October 07, 2001 02:27PM

Re: 16 Hospitals hit

Don Barone October 07, 2001 07:22PM

Re: 16 Hospitals hit

Anthony October 07, 2001 07:28PM

Re: 16 Hospitals hit

ISHMAEL October 08, 2001 06:16AM

Well put, Ishmael

Anthony October 08, 2001 06:53AM

A question for ballistics officianados...

Anthony October 08, 2001 08:53AM

Re: A question for ballistics officianados...

Dave Moore October 08, 2001 09:25AM

Civil war, too

Anthony October 08, 2001 09:34AM

Re: Civil war, too

Anthony October 08, 2001 09:44AM

Different take on food drops

barry October 08, 2001 08:35PM

Re: Different take on food drops

Anthony October 09, 2001 05:55AM

Re: Different take on food drops

JoeRoyle October 09, 2001 09:47AM

Kat's away... squeak...

Anthony October 09, 2001 10:29AM

Re: Mine is the Drop Zone

John D. Miller October 09, 2001 10:35AM

Re: Different take on food drops

Claire October 09, 2001 11:00AM

Re: Different take on food drops

JoeRoyle October 09, 2001 11:14AM

Re: Different take on food drops

Anthony October 09, 2001 11:51AM

Re: Different take on food drops

JoeRoyle October 10, 2001 09:55AM

Re: Different take on food drops

Claire October 09, 2001 12:19PM

100% chance of dying

Anthony October 09, 2001 01:34PM

Now that we have air superiority...

Anthony October 09, 2001 01:40PM

Re: Now that we have air superiority...

JoeRoyle October 10, 2001 09:56AM

Re: Now that we have air superiority...

Anthony October 10, 2001 10:50AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login