Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 4, 2024, 12:00 pm UTC    
September 18, 2001 03:48PM
<HTML>Claire wrote:

> I'm sorry Darius, but I cannot accept demonisation of the German
> people - or the overwhelming majority - whatever. Wars are
> fought with armies commanded by generals - they don't take
> votes on what to do - they are commanded. I agree that the
> Nazis, Hitler et al, are guilty, but not the German people en
> masse. In any case atrocities were committed by both sides,
> as is the case in any war.

****Visit Warsaw Claire, abou every few hundred yards you will see a plaque in memory of couple of hundred of people shot during the street executions. My uncle was shot in one of them. My grandfather died in Aushwitz. And guess what -every single war criminal did it because he was commanded... And BTW how much have you heard about active opposition
to Nazi rule or any sort of underground movement in Germany???

> We're all people - you can't brand whole nations guilty if you ask me.

****I don't brand the whole nation Claire just the guilty and the compliant
ones and there was an awfull lot of them.

>
> BTW did you know how the Afghan army used to kill Russians
> they captured? They cut the skin off their stomachs and laid
> them in the sun to die slowly.
>
****So???? I never said Afganis were nice, just that they are not responsible for the crimes of bin Laden or Taliban

Regards D.P.</HTML>
Subject Author Posted

An Afghan's view

Mark Fagan September 18, 2001 02:18AM

Re: An Afghan's view

Claire September 18, 2001 02:49AM

Re: An Afghan's view

Mark Fagan September 18, 2001 03:27AM

Re: An Afghan's view

Claire September 18, 2001 03:36AM

Re: An Afghan's view

Anonymous User September 18, 2001 06:09AM

Re: An Afghan's view

Claire September 18, 2001 06:51AM

Re: An Afghan's view

Anonymous User September 18, 2001 08:34AM

There are few big differences Claire

D.Przezdziecki September 18, 2001 12:24PM

Re: There are few big differences Claire

Claire September 18, 2001 12:47PM

Re: There are few big differences Claire

D.Przezdziecki September 18, 2001 03:48PM

Re: There are few big differences Claire

Claire September 18, 2001 04:00PM

No fear of offending me Claire

D.Przezdziecki September 18, 2001 04:18PM

Re: An Afghan's view

Robert G. Bauval September 18, 2001 02:52AM

Thanks Mark !

Don Barone September 18, 2001 06:37AM

Re: Thanks Mark !

ISHMAEL September 18, 2001 08:36AM

Re: Thanks Mark !

Katherine Reece September 18, 2001 09:02AM

Re: An Afghan's view

al-Urman September 18, 2001 10:49AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login