creigs1707 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Hermione: Do you have any evidence of this?
>
> SC: Evidence of what precisely? That there was a
> model? That a plan was passed down? What are you
> asking?


Scott,


Back in the game, Scott ?

It is very obvious what Hermione is asking for. It is the same thing as a lot of people asked you many times before ; evidence, which you do not have.

>
> Hermione: As has been pointed out several times
> before, this sort of tradition was not unknown in
> antiquity. The design for Gudea's temple of
> E-ninnu was supposed to have been imparted to him
> by the goddess of knowledge in a dream (an
> architectural plan of a temple actually appears on
> one of his statues). What is more probable: that
> Gudea really did have a dream? Or that architects
> prepared the plans, and that the temple's, and
> Gudea's, close relationship with the gods was then
> emphasised in the account of the so-called dream?
> Again, what is more probably the case with the AE
> temples: did architects prepare plans for them? Or
> did the plans really fall from the heavens in a
> codex?
>
> SC: You are asking a lot of questions here,
> Hermione, and offering very few answers.


Excuse me ??? YOU must offer answers, YOU are the one making silly claims ...


I think
> much of what you have written is open to wide
> interpretation and conjecture. What exactly might
> "...fell from the heavens at Saqqara in the days
> of Imhotep..." mean? To me it could be
> interpreted simply as a plan from the 'gods' - the
> 'gods' meaning people of superior intellect. As
> Newton said: "If I have seen further it is by
> standing upon the shoulders of giants." Imhotep
> may well have received such plans from former
> 'giants of intellect'.


My, my, Scott ! In earlier postings you simply said ; 'it fell down from the sky, right into the hands of Imhotep'. Now, your silly codex have been generated by 'giants of intellect'.


Ronald.