Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument

Home

Discussion Forums

Papers

Authors

Web Links

May 18, 2024, 5:07 am UTC

In: The Hall of Maat > Ancient History - Ancient History and Archaeology > Topic

Goto: Forum List • Create A New Profile • Log In

Ancient History • Ancient Egypt • Laboratory • Humanities • Apocalypse • Paper Lens • Coffee Shop
Exhibitions, Conferences, Lectures, Journals • Alternative Geometry and Numerology

Stephen Tonkin

October 10, 2001 12:17AM

<HTML>Chris Hale wrote:
>
> Does anyone follow this?

I don't. Whatever it is, it's not Ed Krupp's argument (which, I think, you paraphrased very neatly, not that it will make a blind bit of difference to those who are determined to misrepresent it and set up straw men to counter).

[...]
> It is this that makes Ed's argument irrefutable: once you
> accept the shafts, you accept north-south in the sky; one you
> do that you've got an inversion in the alleged Orion
> Correlation.
>
> No amount of waffle about the Nile and whatever the post I am
> responding to is referring to (???) gets round this point!

The only possible 'get-out' that I can see would be an assertion that those who determined the <i>orientation</i> of the pyramids and, especially, the shafts worked entirely independently of (and in ignorance of?) those who determined the <i>relative positions</i> of the pyramids.

> Bauval and co are 'hoist by their own petard'.

Indeed, but surely, Chris, you are not so naive as to believe that deeply-rooted prejudice will allow itself to be diverted by inconvenient things like logic.</HTML>

Reply Quote

Subject	Author	Posted
Invitation for Correction	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 09:25AM
My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 10:08AM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	Chris Hale	October 09, 2001 12:22PM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 12:42PM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 01:12PM
Hey, Chris	Anthony	October 09, 2001 01:19PM
Excellent Post	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 01:36PM
Magnetic North	Anthony	October 09, 2001 02:01PM
Re: Magnetic North	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 02:21PM
Re: Magnetic North	Anthony	October 09, 2001 02:25PM
THE REAL POINT PLEASE?	Chris Hale	October 10, 2001 06:11AM
Re: THE REAL POINT PLEASE?	ISHMAEL	October 10, 2001 07:45AM
Re: Hey, Chris	Chris Hale	October 10, 2001 02:22AM
Thanks Chris.	Derek Barnett	October 09, 2001 03:14PM
Derek???	Anthony	October 09, 2001 03:20PM
Anthony???	Derek Barnett	October 09, 2001 03:30PM
Re: Anthony???	Anonymous User	October 09, 2001 03:38PM
Re: Anthony???	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 07:19PM
Re: Anthony???	Anthony	October 09, 2001 07:23PM
Re: Anthony???	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 07:24AM
Re: Anthony???	John	October 09, 2001 03:53PM
Re: Anthony???	Stephen Tonkin	October 09, 2001 11:14PM
Re: Anthony???	lone	October 10, 2001 04:27AM
Re: Anthony???	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 07:50AM
Re: Anthony???	ISHMAEL	October 10, 2001 07:56AM
Re: Anthony???	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 08:13AM
Re: Anthony???	Anthony	October 10, 2001 08:15AM
Re: Anthony???	Claire	October 10, 2001 08:31AM
Re: Anthony???	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 08:33AM
Hey Duncan!	Claire	October 10, 2001 08:40AM
Re: Hey Claire!	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 08:47AM
Re: Anthony???	lone	October 10, 2001 12:45PM
Re: Thanks Chris.	Claire	October 09, 2001 04:14PM
Cardinal Point Alignment	Anthony	October 09, 2001 05:22PM
Re: Thanks Chris.	Mikey Brass	October 09, 2001 05:37PM
Mikey	Anthony	October 09, 2001 06:36PM
Re: Hieroglyph for North	Greg Reeder	October 09, 2001 07:59PM
Re: Hieroglyph for North	Anthony	October 09, 2001 08:41PM
Re: Hieroglyph for North	Greg Reeder	October 09, 2001 10:20PM
Re: Hieroglyph for North	Anthony	October 10, 2001 06:22AM
Re: Hieroglyph for North	Claire	October 10, 2001 09:02AM
Re: Thanks Chris.	Chris Hale	October 10, 2001 02:28AM
Re: Thanks Chris.	Claire	October 10, 2001 04:38AM
Re: Thanks Chris.	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 04:49AM
Re: Thanks Chris.	Anthony	October 10, 2001 06:31AM
Re: Thanks Chris.	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 07:52AM
Re: Thanks Chris.	ISHMAEL	October 10, 2001 08:04AM
Re: Thanks Chris.	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 08:20AM
Alignment	Anthony	October 10, 2001 08:23AM
Re: Thanks Chris.	ISHMAEL	October 10, 2001 08:01AM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	Don Holeman	October 09, 2001 06:49PM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	Stephen Tonkin	October 10, 2001 12:17AM
Deeply rooted prejudice	Anthony	October 10, 2001 07:00AM
Re: Deeply rooted prejudice	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 08:06AM
Re: Deeply rooted prejudice	Anthony	October 10, 2001 08:12AM
Re: Deeply rooted prejudice	Stephen Tonkin	October 10, 2001 01:39PM
Re: Deeply rooted prejudice	Stephen Tonkin	October 10, 2001 01:23PM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	ISHMAEL	October 10, 2001 08:11AM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 08:28AM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	Stephen Tonkin	October 10, 2001 12:52PM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	Mikey Brass	October 09, 2001 05:32PM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 07:26PM
Repeating and getting it	lone	October 09, 2001 08:43PM
Re: Repeating and getting it	Anthony	October 09, 2001 09:00PM
Re: My Reasons for Not Accepting Krupp's Argument	Greg Reeder	October 09, 2001 08:08PM
Invitation accepted.	Anthony	October 09, 2001 11:57AM
Re: Invitation accepted.	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 12:42PM
To Mr Hale	R. Avry Wilson	October 09, 2001 01:12PM
Re: To Mr Hale	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 01:25PM
Re: To Mr Hale	Robert G. Bauval	October 09, 2001 05:49PM
Coming Out Party	Anthony	October 09, 2001 07:14PM
Well Said!	ISHMAEL	October 09, 2001 07:29PM
Re: Well Said!	Anthony	October 09, 2001 07:54PM
Re: To Mr Hale	Stephen Tonkin	October 09, 2001 11:45PM
Re: To Mr Hale (slight addition -- or is it the correcting of a slight [g])	Stephen Tonkin	October 09, 2001 11:56PM
Re: To Mr Hale	Robert G. Bauval	October 10, 2001 01:44AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Chris Hale	October 10, 2001 02:30AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Robert G. Bauval	October 10, 2001 06:16AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Stephen Tonkin	October 10, 2001 06:32AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Chris Hale	October 10, 2001 05:29PM
Re: To Mr Hale	ISHMAEL	October 10, 2001 08:18AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 08:46AM
Re: To Mr Hale	ISHMAEL	October 10, 2001 10:44AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Stephen Tonkin	October 10, 2001 12:51PM
Re: To Mr Hale	Derek Barnett	October 10, 2001 01:06PM
Re: To Mr Hale	Stephen Tonkin	October 10, 2001 02:07AM
He's back!	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 04:53AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Chris Hale	October 10, 2001 06:34AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Chris Hale	October 10, 2001 02:24AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Robert G. Bauval	October 10, 2001 06:18AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Anonymous User	October 10, 2001 07:13AM
Re: To Mr Hale	Stephen Tonkin	October 10, 2001 01:12PM
For those who still don't get it	R. Avry Wilson	October 09, 2001 10:10PM
Re: For those who still don't get it	Chris Hale	October 10, 2001 06:19AM
Throwing out evidence	Anthony	October 10, 2001 06:48AM
Re: Throwing out evidence	Chris Hale	October 10, 2001 10:43AM
Re: Throwing out evidence	ISHMAEL	October 10, 2001 10:47AM
Re: Throwing out evidence	Mikey Brass	October 10, 2001 03:30PM
typo n/t	R. Avry Wilson	October 09, 2001 10:15PM
Re: typo n/t	al-Urman	October 10, 2001 12:25PM
Chris Hale, and everyone, listen	R. Avry Wilson	October 11, 2001 12:16AM
I told you so. n/t	Don Holeman	October 11, 2001 12:25AM
Re: Chris Hale, and everyone, listen	Chris Hale	October 11, 2001 03:06AM

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login