Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 19, 2024, 9:20 am UTC    
September 07, 2001 05:42AM
<HTML>Hello, John.

There have been hundreds of posts on this board describing the geopolymer theory in SEVERE depth over the last few months. You may want to take a look back.

To sum it up... you are correct about the limited observations that you have recalled. Unfortunately, most of those "coincidences" have been explained by OTHER, more plausible facts that have been discovered... or were already known by others who know the area's geology much better than Davidovits (note: he ends his name with an "S", not a "Z".)

For example, Davidovits' "jumbled shell" observation has been obliterated by the fact that the limestone used for the bulk of his geopolymer process is of a type that will NOT simply dissolve in water.

This has lead to TWO basic solutions to this problem:

1. The limestone needed to be pulverized by hand;
2. A chemical was used to disaggregate the limestone.

Now, in case #1, this would have left SHATTERED shells... not jumbled shells. Oh well, that one is one.

Case #2? Well, what was this chemical? Why have no traces of it EVER been found, and the chemical analysis of the limestone shows it to be exactly the same as the quarry stone?

Of course, there's also the question of the unfinished blocks IN the quarries.

And the clearly demarcated sedimentation lines IN the pyramid/temple blocks that match the ones in the quarry.

And the gaps between blocks that have been filled with gypsum mortar.

etc, etc, etc.


Now, about the diorite vases...

Just because we haven't discovered exactly HOW they were carved (although Archae Solenhofen (sp) does have some AMAZING work he has theorized using a simple bowdrill and a piece of quartz crystal), it does not mean that they used a geopolymer. This geopolymer process has never been reproduced... so it has no more weight than a theory about aliens using rayguns. Sure, it COULD have happened that way...

you get the point.

So, I hope this little post brings you up to speed. Good luck, and glad you could make it.

Anthony</HTML>
Subject Author Posted

3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Frank Doernenburg September 06, 2001 04:26PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

John Wall September 06, 2001 04:33PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Frank Doernenburg September 06, 2001 04:41PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

John Wall September 06, 2001 04:44PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Frank Doernenburg September 06, 2001 05:00PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Don Holeman September 10, 2001 10:39PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Anthony September 06, 2001 06:20PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Frank Doernenburg September 06, 2001 06:32PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Anthony September 06, 2001 07:00PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Sandy J. Perkins September 06, 2001 07:52PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Anthony September 07, 2001 05:28AM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Sandy J. Perkins September 06, 2001 07:49PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Frank Doernenburg September 07, 2001 05:27AM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Sandy J. Perkins September 07, 2001 07:33PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Katherine Reece September 07, 2001 11:15PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Sandy J. Perkins September 08, 2001 06:04PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Frank Doernenburg September 08, 2001 06:35PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Sandy J. Perkins September 08, 2001 10:14PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Frank Doernenburg September 09, 2001 05:34AM

Where Are Your Trials?

Sandy J. Perkins September 09, 2001 07:33PM

Re: Where Are Your Trials?

Frank Doernenburg September 10, 2001 05:05AM

Re: Where Are Your Trials?

Sandy J. Perkins September 10, 2001 09:34PM

Re: Where Are Your Trials?

Frank Doernenburg September 11, 2001 04:27AM

Re: Where Are Your Trials?

Sandy J. Perkins September 11, 2001 11:07PM

Re: Where Are Your Trials?

Anthony September 11, 2001 06:35AM

Re: Where Are Your Trials?

Sandy J. Perkins September 14, 2001 11:09PM

Inappropriate argument style

Anthony September 09, 2001 06:57AM

Re: Inappropriate argument style

Sandy J. Perkins September 09, 2001 07:37PM

Look over there... not at my theory!

Anthony September 10, 2001 07:24AM

Re: Look over there... not at my theory!

John Wall September 10, 2001 07:48AM

Re: Look over there... not at my theory!

Anthony September 10, 2001 08:04AM

Won't work, Anthony. Bad try.

Sandy J. Perkins September 12, 2001 12:06AM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Sandy J. Perkins September 06, 2001 07:44PM

Re: 3rd question to Mrs. Morris

Frank Doernenburg September 07, 2001 03:21AM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

sandy September 06, 2001 07:56PM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

Blue September 06, 2001 08:24PM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

sandy September 07, 2001 03:00AM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

Frank Doernenburg September 07, 2001 03:39AM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

sandy September 07, 2001 07:08AM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

Blue September 07, 2001 07:57PM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

Sandy J. Perkins September 17, 2001 02:50AM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

Sandy J. Perkins September 17, 2001 02:53AM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

J.H.v.d.Laar September 06, 2001 10:42PM

Welcome, John

Anthony September 07, 2001 05:42AM

Re: Welcome, John

Sandy J. Perkins September 07, 2001 07:42PM

Re: Welcome, John

Chris Dunn September 07, 2001 08:46PM

Welcome, Chris

Anthony September 07, 2001 09:30PM

Re: Welcome, Chris

Chris Dunn September 07, 2001 09:40PM

Re: Welcome, Chris

Anthony September 07, 2001 09:58PM

Re: Welcome, Chris

Katherine Reece September 07, 2001 11:11PM

Re: Welcome, John

Sandy J. Perkins September 08, 2001 06:10PM

Re: Welcome, John

Chris Dunn September 09, 2001 07:36AM

Re: Welcome, John

Sandy J. Perkins September 09, 2001 07:56PM

Re: Welcome, John

Blue September 10, 2001 08:10PM

Re: Welcome, John

Sandy J. Perkins September 10, 2001 09:47PM

Re: Welcome, John

Archae Solenhofen September 11, 2001 02:09AM

Re: Welcome, John

Sandy J. Perkins September 17, 2001 03:23AM

Re: Welcome, John

Frank Doernenburg September 17, 2001 08:55AM

Re: Welcome, John

Sandy J. Perkins September 20, 2001 07:40AM

Done reading....

Anthony September 07, 2001 11:35PM

Re: Done reading....

Blue September 09, 2001 09:39AM

Anthony's Distortions

Sandy J. Perkins September 09, 2001 07:59PM

Sandy's heckling

Claire September 10, 2001 03:50AM

Re: Sandy's heckling

John Wall September 10, 2001 04:48AM

Re: Sandy's heckling

Claire September 10, 2001 05:15AM

Re: Sandy's heckling

John Wall September 10, 2001 05:18AM

Re: Sandy's heckling

Claire September 10, 2001 05:30AM

Re: Sandy's heckling

John Wall September 10, 2001 06:15AM

Re: Sandy's heckling

Frank Doernenburg September 10, 2001 06:22PM

Fair Protocol Isn't Heckling

Sandy J. Perkins September 10, 2001 09:56PM

You want &quot;fair&quot;?

Anthony September 11, 2001 06:42AM

Re: You want &quot;fair&quot;?

Sandy J. Perkins September 11, 2001 11:58PM

Re: Sandy's heckling

Sandy J. Perkins September 10, 2001 10:04PM

Re: Sandy's heckling

Claire September 11, 2001 03:45AM

Re: Done reading....

Sandy J. Perkins September 12, 2001 12:58AM

Re: Done reading....

Sandy J. Perkins September 12, 2001 01:03AM

Re: Welcome, John

Frank Doernenburg September 08, 2001 06:01AM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

Frank Doernenburg September 07, 2001 03:15AM

Re: 3rd question, something's not right

sandy September 07, 2001 07:13AM

Problems

jameske September 08, 2001 02:13PM

Re: Problems

Anthony September 08, 2001 03:35PM

Re: Problems

Sandy J. Perkins September 08, 2001 06:16PM

Re: Problems

Paul Mattock September 10, 2001 06:50AM

Re: Problems

Paul Mattock September 10, 2001 06:51AM

Answer from the wrong camp

Anthony September 10, 2001 07:32AM

Re: Problems

Sandy J. Perkins September 10, 2001 10:09PM

Re: Problems

Blue September 12, 2001 09:01AM

Re: Problems

Sandy J. Perkins September 14, 2001 11:17PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login