Graham,

At the start of the thread [www.hallofmaat.com], you claimed:

"Two weeks ago I presented a new and planned geometry of Giza.
It has been verified by Don and Wayne beyond doubt.
It has been proven incontrovertibly by mathematics."

I posted a link to a webpage on mathematical proofs. Someone with mathematical qualifications should surely be able to produce a mathematical proof that satisfies one of the criteria identified in that page. You've claimed "proven incontrovertibly by mathematics": that's an unequivocal claim. But, on the evidence so far presented, you cannot substantiate it.

> The meaning of relevance here is 'relevent to the
> symbolism'.

No, this is not what you claimed. You announced a "new and planned geometry of Giza". But now you seem to have retreated from that position, and are citing instead just two out of the three main pyramids.

> The other related buildings and structures may not
> be part of that stellar symbolism but perhaps are
> part of other patterns.

But this statement makes no sense. Where is the stellar symbolism in the Giza pyramids? The only explicitly stellar 4th dynasty pyramid is Djedefre's, at Abu Rowash.

In terms of stellar symbolism, the north chapel can be considered as a
continuation of the earlier north-south complex orientation. So the north chapel certainly has strongly stellar links.

> Sorry - but my theory did predict. By taking 2
> simple rules of the proposed geometric relations I
> was able to predict the precise size of G1 and G3
> from it. Do you know of any other proof that has
> been able to do that ??

Remember that what you did was to take two stars and rotate them so that they were
at 45 degrees. But you've provided no contemporary textual support for such a procedure. Your 45 degrees came from the supposed angle between Giza and Heliopolis; but a previous post explained how Heliopolis eventually extended over a very large area. I repeat: you have no justification for this angle. If yours was a truly predictive theory, it would allow you to include all three of the Giza pyramids, plus all the other relevant structures, and would also work at other pyramid fields.

Hermione
Director/Moderator - The Hall of Ma'at

Rules and Guidelines

hallofmaatforum@proton.me