Jason Colavito Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------

> Richard A. Lupov is a Hugo-award winning science
> ficiton author, but it was clear from his review
> that he had only read the *uncorrected* galley
> proofs of my book, not the published work.

I hadnl't realized that until you said ...


It
> isn't quite nice to criticize me for mistakes that
> were corrected before publication.

Hmmm ... almost smacks of shoddy research, one might say ...

>
> Actually, it was clear from Lupov's discussion
> that he only read selected chapters of the book
> and in fact cribbed the rest of his review from
> the press release.

He's not the only reviewer who's guilty of this sort of thing ...


> Anyway, I'm sure this will be more humorous after
> I'm done being sad that all of southern California
> heard this review.

At least it is publicity, even if not the most flattering sort ...

Hermione
Director/Moderator - The Hall of Ma'at

Rules and Guidelines

hallofmaatforum@proton.me