Re: Coincidence?

Home

Discussion Forums

Papers

Authors

Web Links

May 17, 2024, 7:50 am UTC

In: The Hall of Maat > Ancient History - Ancient History and Archaeology > Topic

Goto: Forum List • Create A New Profile • Log In

Ancient History • Ancient Egypt • Laboratory • Humanities • Apocalypse • Paper Lens • Coffee Shop
Exhibitions, Conferences, Lectures, Journals • Alternative Geometry and Numerology

John Wall

September 27, 2001 10:15AM

Registered: 19 years ago
Posts: 11,732

<HTML>Claire wrote:
>
> >>They're supposed to be very good ! I know people in their
> 70s who enjoy them. I've got too much to read myself......
>
> I enjoyed them - but then I've very immature anyway so they
> were pitched about right lol

I'm sure you're not !

> BTW I agree with RB about the Ed Krupp thing - I can't see
> what point Ed Krupp is making really - I don't think that
> it's exactly the best argument against the OCT myself :-)
> I'm interested to see what RB's reply to this thread is
> though......

Have you read what Ed Krupp <a href="[www.ianlawton.com]; ? I had to read it couple of times myself !

He's basically saying that Bauval/Gilbert associate a northern shaft with a northern star and a southern shaft with a southern star. In that case the orientation of Giza is upside down.

He also, initially, states:

I am not as interested in establishing what the Egyptians did or didn't do as I am in understanding and evaluating accurately the Orion mapping assertion Bauval and Gilbert originally developed in "The Orion Mystery" and that Hancock and Bauval extended in "The Message of the Sphinx".

He's looking at the "internal consistency" of the argument and, on one of the threads on this MB, RB IIRC admitted that he was "technically" right.

Thinking it through it's clear what the implications are:

(1) If the shafts were targeted at stars then Giza is upside down.

(2) If Giza is the right way up then the shafts weren't targeted at stars. But the shaft - supposedly - targeting Orion's Belt is RB's primary link between Giza and Orion's Belt......

How did I do ?

John</HTML>

Reply Quote

Subject	Author	Posted
Coincidence?	Anonymous User	September 27, 2001 07:37AM
Re: Coincidence?	Claire	September 27, 2001 08:23AM
Re: Coincidence?	John Wall	September 27, 2001 08:28AM
Re: Coincidence?	Mikey Brass	September 27, 2001 08:43AM
Re: Coincidence?	John Wall	September 27, 2001 08:46AM
Re: Coincidence?	Claire	September 27, 2001 08:44AM
Re: Coincidence?	John Wall	September 27, 2001 08:48AM
Re: Coincidence?	Claire	September 27, 2001 08:53AM
Re: Coincidence?	John Wall	September 27, 2001 08:58AM
Re: Coincidence?	Claire	September 27, 2001 09:35AM
Re: Coincidence?	John Wall	September 27, 2001 09:41AM
Re: Coincidence?	Claire	September 27, 2001 09:56AM
Re: Coincidence?	John Wall	September 27, 2001 10:15AM
Re: Coincidence?	Claire	September 27, 2001 10:42AM
Re: Coincidence?	John Wall	September 27, 2001 10:55AM
Re: Coincidence?	Anonymous User	September 27, 2001 09:38AM
Re: Coincidence?	Claire	September 27, 2001 09:53AM
Robert's Opinion and More	ISHMAEL	September 27, 2001 10:40AM
Re: Robert's Opinion and More	Anonymous User	September 27, 2001 12:06PM
Re: Coincidence?	John	September 27, 2001 11:47AM
Re: Coincidence?	Robert G. Bauval	September 27, 2001 12:36PM
Re: Coincidence?	Anonymous User	September 27, 2001 01:35PM
Re: Coincidence?	ISHMAEL	September 27, 2001 02:00PM
Re: Coincidence?	Anonymous User	September 27, 2001 02:07PM
Re: Coincidence?	ISHMAEL	September 27, 2001 01:56PM
Re: Coincidence?	Anonymous User	September 27, 2001 03:09PM
Re: Coincidence?	John	September 27, 2001 03:56PM
Re: Coincidence?	Mikey Brass	September 27, 2001 04:16PM
Re: Coincidence?	Robert G. Bauval	September 27, 2001 04:33PM
Re: Coincidence?	ISHMAEL	September 28, 2001 08:09AM
Re: Coincidence?	Mikey Brass	September 27, 2001 01:12PM
Re: Coincidence?	Anonymous User	September 27, 2001 01:41PM
Anthony's Error	ISHMAEL	September 27, 2001 02:26PM
Re: Anthony's Error	Claire	September 27, 2001 02:36PM
Short Answer	ISHMAEL	September 27, 2001 02:40PM
Re: Coincidence?	R. Avry Wilson	September 27, 2001 04:16PM
Re: Coincidence?	Claire	September 27, 2001 04:23PM
Re: Coincidence?	Anonymous User	September 27, 2001 05:11PM
Wrong Wrong Wrong!	ISHMAEL	September 28, 2001 08:14AM
Can I weigh in on this? lol	Anthony	September 27, 2001 05:50PM
Re: Can I weigh in on this? lol	Mikey Brass	September 27, 2001 06:53PM
Okay, call me dense...	Anthony	September 27, 2001 07:13PM
Re: Okay, call me dense...	Mikey Brass	September 28, 2001 02:14AM
Mikey/Avry	Anthony	September 28, 2001 06:21AM
Re: Mikey/Avry	Mikey Brass	September 28, 2001 06:33AM
Re: Mikey/Avry	Anthony	September 28, 2001 09:36AM
Re: Mikey/Avry	Stephen Tonkin	September 29, 2001 12:01AM
Stephen	Anthony	September 29, 2001 06:15AM
Re: Stephen	Stephen Tonkin	September 29, 2001 09:38AM
Re: Stephen	Anthony	September 29, 2001 04:43PM
Re: Mikey/Avry	Mikey Brass	October 01, 2001 03:16AM
Eh?	R. Avry Wilson	September 28, 2001 02:29AM
Re: Eh?	Anonymous User	September 28, 2001 04:30AM
Re: Eh?	Peter VanderZwet	September 28, 2001 05:03AM
Claire/Anthony	R. Avry Wilson	September 28, 2001 02:48AM
Re: Coincidence?	sandy	September 29, 2001 05:20PM
Re: Coincidence?	sandy	September 29, 2001 05:44PM
Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	Anthony	September 30, 2001 05:44AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	John Wall	September 30, 2001 09:37AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	Anthony	September 30, 2001 07:34PM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	sandy	September 30, 2001 08:20PM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	John Wall	October 01, 2001 05:30AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	sandy	October 01, 2001 05:35AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	John Wall	October 01, 2001 05:42AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	sandy	October 01, 2001 05:45AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	Anthony	October 01, 2001 07:21AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	John Wall	October 01, 2001 07:38AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	John Wall	October 01, 2001 05:24AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	sandy	October 01, 2001 05:31AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	John Wall	October 01, 2001 05:39AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	sandy	October 01, 2001 05:55AM
According to my Analysis....	Anthony	October 01, 2001 07:27AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	John Wall	October 01, 2001 07:44AM
Re: Accuracy in the 3rd Millenium BCE	sandy	October 01, 2001 05:58AM

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login