Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 17, 2024, 12:00 pm UTC    
September 18, 2001 04:48AM
<HTML>Pathetic. First you cite a 1919 book. It's based on speculation because the Giza quarries weren't studied by the author--right Frank? Read Arnold and Klemm--the Old and Middle Kingdom quarry walls are covered with marks made by pointed picks. This has no relationship to the iron twist forks used on travertine in the 19th century or other old methods. And quarrying with pointed picks, probably made of stone, has no relationship to modern methods, like chains saws used to slice up quarry faces.

The real point is one you ignore. As I said, go figure the waste. There's no getting around it. After clearing 30 feet (compare the depth of the Giza quarry walls!) or so of waste rock from the top surface (good for concrete) of any quarry count on a 30 to 50 % waste factor with modern means. Talk to a real modern limestone quarryman who uses the best methods rather than reading old books. Then figure the waste from making trenches around blocks as you claim took place (even though there's not enough evidence of this to account for the GP according to Petrie and Waseda geologists--see Morris post). The waste is too high and the quarries identified too small; more must be conjectured to fudge the problem.

You're in over your head Frank and you must know that. Either that or its the comprehension problem I outlined earlier.

Sandy</HTML>
Subject Author Posted

Limestone cutting

John Wall September 10, 2001 07:46AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Anthony September 10, 2001 07:59AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Frank Doernenburg September 10, 2001 08:02AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Anthony September 10, 2001 08:10AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Sandy J. Perkins September 10, 2001 09:14PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Frank Doernenburg September 11, 2001 04:23AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Sandy J. Perkins September 11, 2001 10:31PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Frank Doernenburg September 12, 2001 05:38AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Mercury Rapids September 10, 2001 08:39AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Anthony September 10, 2001 08:57AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Sandy J. Perkins September 10, 2001 09:19PM

75% Waste?

Anthony September 11, 2001 06:26AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Frank Doernenburg September 11, 2001 06:49AM

Sandy... Please cite your source

Anthony September 11, 2001 01:46PM

Re: Sandy... Please cite your source

Sandy J. Perkins September 14, 2001 10:52PM

Re: Sandy... Please cite your source

Frank Doernenburg September 17, 2001 04:25AM

Re: Sandy... Please cite your source

Sand J. Perkins September 18, 2001 04:48AM

Re: Sandy... Please cite your source

Frank Doernenburg September 18, 2001 05:43AM

Re: Sandy... Please cite your source

Sandy J. Perkins September 19, 2001 10:07AM

Re: Sandy... Please cite your source

Frank Doernenburg September 19, 2001 05:12PM

Re: Sandy... Please cite your source

Sandy J. Perkins September 20, 2001 07:22AM

Re: Sandy... Please cite your source

Frank Doernenburg September 21, 2001 08:51AM

Re: Sandy... Please cite your source

Sandy J. Perkins September 22, 2001 01:24PM

Re: Limestone cutting

John Wall September 10, 2001 09:27AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Katherine Reece September 10, 2001 09:27AM

Re: Limestone cutting

John Wall September 10, 2001 09:32AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Mikey Brass September 10, 2001 12:14PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Frank Doernenburg September 10, 2001 12:32PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Sandy J. Perkins September 10, 2001 09:20PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Archae Solenhofen September 10, 2001 10:29AM

Re: Limestone cutting

John Wall September 10, 2001 10:32AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Archae Solenhofen September 10, 2001 01:04PM

Re: Limestone cutting

John Wall September 10, 2001 01:10PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Archae Solenhofen September 10, 2001 01:27PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Sandy J. Perkins September 18, 2001 04:28AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Sandy J. Perkins September 10, 2001 09:25PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Frank Doernenburg September 10, 2001 10:58AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Archae Solenhofen September 10, 2001 11:44AM

Re: Limestone cutting

Frank Doernenburg September 10, 2001 05:18PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Archae Solenhofen September 10, 2001 06:22PM

Re: Limestone cutting

Frank Doernenburg September 10, 2001 06:34PM

Old Kingdom Tomb of Kaemrehu

Jon B September 11, 2001 03:01PM

Re: Old Kingdom Tomb of Kaemrehu

John Wall September 11, 2001 03:43PM

URL for Kaemrehu

Jon B September 11, 2001 04:21PM

Let's see if this works ?

John Wall September 11, 2001 04:40PM

Eureka !

John Wall September 11, 2001 04:40PM

Re: URL for Kaemrehu

Archae Solenhofen September 11, 2001 06:02PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login