Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 6, 2024, 10:33 am UTC    
August 27, 2001 02:58PM
<HTML>
> Doesn't phase me as I don't have to live by the rules others
> set (nor do you).

There are protocols of method by which historical investigation is done. See "Three Principles" here in the articles.

> Are the pyramid texts hard evidence?

Yes, but their interpretation is highly contentious and they date to millennia after the pyramids. You don't see any problem with that?
>

> So, hard science of astronomy (Van Flandern) requires
> interpretation? What doesn't?

The astronomical data might be self-evident (I'm not an astronomer, so I don't know) but the link to AE sure as heck isn't.

> I'm sure Tompkins/Steccini is just impressing on a structure
> numbers that ANY structure could be forced to encode.

Pretty much. In the 1950s mathematician Martin Gardner "discovered" the property of 55-ness in the Washington monument in DC. It was totally meaningless, of course, but he used it as a solid example of how simple and well proportioned monuments can be manipulated mathematically once you have enough proportions and variables, the patience, and the arithmatical skill. Doesn't say anything, necessarily, about the intentions of the builders.

> How is reading the Pyramid texts as well as all the more
> notable literature of Egypt not a real staple of archeology?

Archaeology deals with the physical remains of the past, not the written evidence (which is up to philologists and epigraphers to work on).

>
> I beg to differ. In the long run, only one of us will be
> proven correct.

That's your prerogative, but you haven't answered my objection: your list of "evidence" is no evidence, just speculation dressed up as "evidence."

Where are the houses, the burials, the hatpins of the LC'ers?

Garrett</HTML>
Subject Author Posted

What is the evidence?

Katherine Reece August 27, 2001 10:03AM

Re: What is the evidence?

Jim Lewandowski August 27, 2001 10:27AM

Re: What is the evidence?

Garrett Fagan August 27, 2001 11:24AM

Re: What is the evidence?

Jim Lewandowski August 27, 2001 11:31AM

Oops. Forgot, Garrett.

Jim Lewandowski August 27, 2001 11:33AM

Re: Oops. Forgot, Garrett.

Claire August 27, 2001 11:53AM

Re: Oops. Forgot, Garrett.

Jim Lewandowski August 27, 2001 12:21PM

Re: Oops. Forgot, Garrett.

Claire August 27, 2001 12:27PM

Re: What is the evidence?

Garrett Fagan August 27, 2001 02:58PM

Re: What is the evidence?

Stephen Tonkin August 27, 2001 04:17PM

Rebutting the Big Bang Rebuttals

Dave Moore August 27, 2001 06:27PM

Re: What is the evidence?

jim Lewandowski August 27, 2001 05:07PM

Re: What is the evidence?

Garrett August 27, 2001 08:09PM

Re: What is the evidence?

JoeRoyle August 28, 2001 03:32AM

Re: What is the evidence?

Garrett August 28, 2001 05:24PM

Re: What is the evidence?

Katherine Reece August 27, 2001 01:21PM

Re: What is the evidence?

jim Lewandowski August 27, 2001 05:00PM

Re: What is the evidence?

lone August 27, 2001 10:24PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login