Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

April 30, 2024, 10:04 am UTC    
August 17, 2001 03:46PM
<HTML>Perhaps I should file this message away. I've written it often enough elsewhere.

Back in the late 1970s Wendorf have across some grains that looked like they were of domesticated stock. Then they had the grindstones and the sickle gloss. Yes the information was published by Wendorf and Schild, and Hoffman picked it up and repeated the info. Slight problem though... Back then, all the way back at the start, there was a rumour going around that a student had planted the grains in the laboratory as a practical joke. Further investigation has shown the grains were indeed, to be politically correct, "intrusive" into the deposits examined (whether they were planted is another matter) and the grindstones and sickle gloss were the result of activities other than agricultural harvesting.

I submit that as Hoffman's book was 16 years old by the time FOG was released, Hancock should have sort independent confirmation for this information and inquired whether or not additional research had been undertaken into this matter. If he had done so he would have found that the academic who disproved the experimental agricultural idea was Fred Wendorf, nearly a decade before FOG was released..

Mike.</HTML>
Subject Author Posted

Has the FOG Cleared?

Garrett Fagan August 17, 2001 12:13PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Peter VanderZwet August 17, 2001 12:45PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Claire August 17, 2001 12:58PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Peter VanderZwet August 17, 2001 01:13PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Martin Stower August 17, 2001 01:21PM

~rotflmao~

Katherine Reece August 17, 2001 01:22PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Peter VanderZwet August 17, 2001 01:26PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Peter VanderZwet August 17, 2001 01:25PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Don Holeman August 17, 2001 01:47PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Dave Moore August 17, 2001 02:15PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Mikey Brass August 17, 2001 03:46PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

dholeman August 18, 2001 12:19AM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Mikey Brass August 18, 2001 03:10AM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Garrett Fagan August 17, 2001 02:48PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Greg Reeder August 17, 2001 03:43PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Garrett Fagan August 17, 2001 04:09PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Mikey Brass August 17, 2001 04:10PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Greg Reeder August 17, 2001 04:41PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Garrett August 18, 2001 02:01PM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Stephen Tonkin August 19, 2001 01:45AM

Re: Has the FOG Cleared?

Garrett August 19, 2001 07:34PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login