Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

April 28, 2024, 3:26 pm UTC    
December 22, 2020 12:28PM
If the logs are indeed radial, then one could probably take a core sample and do a radiocarbon wiggle match, to get a more precise felling date for the logs.

However, there would be an issue with this that is inherent with the unfortunate shape of the radiocarbon calibration curve at the time of the Old Kingdom. The issue is that there is a so-called radiocarbon plateau at this point in time. What this means is that for a broad length of time the radiocarbon curve remains relatively flat (rather than decreasing as one moves forward in time). So when you try to calibrate a radiocarbon date, regardless of that radiocarbon ages precision, you will get a large uncertainty in its calibrated date.

So below is an example. I have taken an average radiocarbon age from two samples associated with Sneferu (this would be a piece of textile and a short lived plant material radiocarbon ages of 4090 +/- 29 and 4140 +/- 30 BP, to average 4125 +/- 30 BP, both of which taken from Meidum) (See here Bronk Ramsay et al 2010 [www.researchgate.net]. Using this radiocarbon age I have calibrated it against IntCal20 and obtained the following graph




You can see that this radiocarbon calibration would give a date for the material as being about a 1 in 3 probability the material dates to 2870-2800 and a 2 in 3 probability that it dates between 2775 and 2580. Overall this is a 300 year spread of possible dates, and recall that this is on samples from short lived material thought to come from Sneferu's reign. Should the logs in the bent pyramid have been felled in the reign of Sneferu then that even with a wiggle-match we may not get a precise date for their outer ring. We might get lucky though.


It is worth noting though that Bronk Ramsay et al. 2010, was able to obtain a calendar date for Sneferu between 2649-2582 (at 95.4% probability) by using a Baysian analysis of the sequence of radiocarbon dates of a large number of dates associated with many different kings. These radiocarbon dates would have been obtained from carefully selected samples, virtually all from short lived samples. This would likely have been because of the problem of not knowing which part of a tree a wooden sample came from, or indeed if the wood had even been reclaimed and re-purposed.

Jonny

The path to good scholarship is paved with imagined patterns. - David M Raup
Subject Author Posted

Dixon relic found?

waggy December 16, 2020 02:55AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hermione December 16, 2020 04:17AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hermione December 16, 2020 04:41AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Pistol December 17, 2020 06:50PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 17, 2020 09:56PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Pistol December 18, 2020 06:01PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 19, 2020 03:25AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 19, 2020 11:03PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

JonnyMcA December 18, 2020 11:24AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 18, 2020 11:45AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

JonnyMcA December 18, 2020 04:17PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Pistol December 18, 2020 06:59PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

JonnyMcA December 19, 2020 11:56AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Pistol December 19, 2020 06:49PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

JonnyMcA December 19, 2020 07:53PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Pistol December 19, 2020 07:57PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Pistol December 19, 2020 06:02AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

engbren December 16, 2020 06:35AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

mstower December 16, 2020 10:50AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 16, 2020 11:15AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

mstower December 16, 2020 12:38PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 16, 2020 12:58PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hermione December 16, 2020 01:16PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 16, 2020 01:28PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

mstower December 16, 2020 05:46PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 16, 2020 06:06PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hermione December 16, 2020 11:52AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 16, 2020 01:04PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hermione December 16, 2020 03:08PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 16, 2020 05:39PM

The Creighton Wakes

mstower December 17, 2020 09:32AM

Re: The Creighton Wakes

Hermione December 17, 2020 11:31AM

Creighton’s Refinement

mstower December 19, 2020 02:33PM

Re: Creighton’s Refinement

Hans December 19, 2020 04:08PM

Re: Creighton’s Refinement

Hermione December 20, 2020 03:03AM

A Note on a Quote

mstower December 20, 2020 10:53AM

Slippin’ and Slidin’

mstower December 20, 2020 05:14PM

Is that all there is?

mstower December 20, 2020 07:40PM

As noted previously

mstower December 21, 2020 10:33AM

What’s a thousand years?

mstower December 20, 2020 07:00PM

Re: What’s a thousand years?

Hans December 20, 2020 07:58PM

Re: What’s a thousand years?

mstower December 20, 2020 08:39PM

Re: Creighton’s Refinement

Hans December 20, 2020 07:55PM

Re: Creighton’s Refinement

mstower December 20, 2020 08:42PM

Re: Creighton’s Refinement

Hans December 20, 2020 10:13PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hans December 16, 2020 11:03AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

JonnyMcA December 18, 2020 11:36AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hermione December 20, 2020 03:10AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

waggy December 21, 2020 04:33AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Pistol December 21, 2020 10:51AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

JonnyMcA December 21, 2020 11:51AM

Re: Dixon relic found?

waggy December 21, 2020 12:57PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

JonnyMcA December 22, 2020 12:28PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

waggy December 22, 2020 02:04PM

Re: Dixon relic found?

Hermione December 21, 2020 01:32PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login