Guys, there’s some history here you should know about. PZ Myers has had a hate on for EP for some time, for reasons that appear to be more political than scientific. This article is more temperately written than most of his, and presents a veneer of PZ knowing what he’s talking about, but he is in fact grossly misrepresenting an entire field of respectable and exciting scientific research. Scroll down to Comment #144, a detailed critique of Myers’ post by someone who is familiar with the literature, and active in EP research.
Also, I’ve recently presented a more informal critique of some of PZ’s previous pronouncements at:
[
skepticink.com]
Bernard is absolutely correct that the popular media get things wrong, and their reports on EP studies should be viewed with caution; but there is a bouncing baby in the bathwater that PZ Myers and his ilk are so keen to throw out.