Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 3, 2024, 1:44 am UTC    
Mark K.
March 22, 2005 09:51PM
Seems Nathan Wilson’s experiment is caught in the ‘popular news item vortex’. Articles showing up not only in the local press, but some national attention also. Unfortunately, as his work becomes big news it also shows signs of unraveling once any hard questions are asked, or even semi-hard ones. And those questions are starting to be asked and the unraveling has begun. A couple of the problems: First, Nate's work supposed the image on the shroud was composed of a dye, most likely red ochre. The problem is red ochre is stable in sunlight, it does NOT fade. The pigment in brick is basically red ochre. A brick does not fade because red ochre does not fade. The image on the shroud is not a dye of ANY kind. That hypothesis was considered, tested, and discarded decades ago. Secondly,the state of forteenth century glass making is another obvious problem(see website).

[www.shroudstory.com]

And it doesn’t stop there. Seems Nate’s research prior to his experiment was less than adequate.
Nate’s claim is looking similar to the man who declares he knows how Michelangelo created his David, since he’s just created a replica with his chainsaw and a log. However, we know David is not made of wood, and Michelangelo predates the invention of chainsaws. Well, the shroud is not made of a dye of any kind, and glass the size needed didn’t exist for another 300 years, at least.
Mark K
Subject Author Posted

Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Simon March 07, 2005 02:20PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

John Wall March 07, 2005 03:14PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Simon March 07, 2005 04:45PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

John Wall March 07, 2005 06:20PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Simon March 07, 2005 06:35PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

John Wall March 07, 2005 06:48PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Anthony March 08, 2005 07:53AM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Janja March 08, 2005 10:20AM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Simon March 08, 2005 06:33PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Anthony March 09, 2005 01:33PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Mark K. March 22, 2005 09:51PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

John Wall March 23, 2005 03:58AM

Ma'at suggested it first winking smiley

kenuchelover March 08, 2005 02:28PM

Well..... let's get this RIGHT

Anthony March 09, 2005 01:36PM

Re: Well..... let's get this RIGHT

kenuchelover March 09, 2005 02:37PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Pacal March 08, 2005 06:30PM

Re: Experiment: "Turin Shroud An Easy Forgery"

Voltaire March 09, 2005 10:17AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login