Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 15, 2024, 9:33 pm UTC    
February 03, 2005 09:44AM
Yes I agree with that completely in general. But there are ways of doing it that are better than others. Like Star Trek or Stargate both have completely fictional science - but they at least do some research to make it so that its not completely twisting what we know. With historical films or books there are ways they can be written where the details are all made up - but they are at least within the context of what happened. Or they can be made as complete fantasy just set in the loose context of what happened. But with films like Braveheart they are neither one nor the other. They are made as if they are a fair representation of what happened, when they are a deliberate distortion of the fundamental reality. Thats when I do have a problem.

With Dan Brown I'm more and more surprised how many people take what he writes about history and religion seriously. Its another Braveheart kind of thing where what should be taken as fiction in fact gets accepted (at least subconsciously) by anyone who doesn't know enough to know better. I guess its a question of artistic license and what that means. Like if you made a film that showed various people inventing the story of the Holocaust - I think that would be going too far. But if a film was made where Hitler had one that battle of britain and showed britain occupied by the Nazis - I don't see any problem with that at all. Does that make sense ?
Subject Author Posted

Pope John Paul ll in hospital

laura February 02, 2005 03:07AM

Re: Pope John Paul ll in hospital

Mercury Rapids February 02, 2005 05:42AM

Re: Pope John Paul ll in hospital

laura February 02, 2005 05:51AM

Re: Pope John Paul ll in hospital

Dave L February 02, 2005 07:55AM

Re: Pope John Paul ll in hospital

laura February 02, 2005 09:14AM

angels and demons

Robert LaFrance February 02, 2005 02:18PM

aha

Warwick L Nixon February 02, 2005 02:28PM

Re: angels and demons

Simon February 02, 2005 05:35PM

Re: angels and demons

Stephanie February 02, 2005 08:09PM

Re: angels and demons

Simon February 03, 2005 09:44AM

Re: angels and demons

steven pyatt February 03, 2005 05:38PM

Re: angels and demons

Simon February 03, 2005 07:51PM

Re: angels and demons

steven pyatt February 04, 2005 07:31AM

and besides...

Simon February 03, 2005 03:05PM

Re: Pope John Paul ll in hospital

Robert LaFrance February 02, 2005 02:06PM

actually

Warwick L Nixon February 02, 2005 02:08PM

Re: actually

Simon February 02, 2005 05:39PM

Re: actually

steven pyatt February 03, 2005 09:19AM

Re: actually

Simon February 03, 2005 09:47AM

Re: actually

steven pyatt February 03, 2005 06:08PM

Re: actually

Simon February 03, 2005 07:47PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login