Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 18, 2024, 9:09 pm UTC    
July 14, 2017 02:34PM
I read through all 77 pages of the Library of Congress link dated May 9, 1910 and find no evidence that the KRS is fake. In fact the comments on page 35 would indicate that it is not a ‘modern forgery’.

“The exactness with which the location of the camp is described can be attributed to the probable burial of the ten men at the camp, and the natural desire to describe geographically the place of the bloody massacre of ten of their comrades; while the agreement of this exactness with the facts in nature shows how improbable it was for a faker runologist to have made the inscription. If the record be fraudulent, it is a remarkable fact that those two skerries exist, and at the right distance, and that there are no others.* * Other lakes in the vicinity, within a possible range of twenty miles, have been searched over by Prof. Fossum, Rev. O. A. Norman, and Mr. H. R. Holand, without finding anything that could be called “two skerries.” It is still more remarkable, on the hypothesis that the stone 251 is fraudulent, that within modern times they could not be called skerries, as they are not now surrounded by water. Hence the impostor-scribe was not only a runologist, but he was able to look backward through the physical change that has come over the region, and to describe those boulders as they were 548 years ago, when there is no doubt that the water of the lake was so high as to surround them and thus warrant the description which he made of them. He must have been a geologist. If the record is fraudulent, it is also remarkable that the impostor could see that 548 years ago the hill on which the stone was placed was surrounded by water so as to warrant the application of the term “island.” He must have known, and must have made allowance for the fact, that within recent time the country has dried up considerably, and that what are now marshes were then lakes. If the stone be fraudulent, it is singular that the impostor ran the risk of all these details and violated none of them. A well considered fraud is usually characterized by the omission of details. Here was a recklessness and a fearlessness amongst details which betoken honesty and truth. The very discrepancies, where the details diverge from present geographic knowledge, when correctly understood are turned to so many points of confirmation.”

And

“It appears, from several considerations, that the scribe was a rather illiterate Swede. If the stone be fraudulent, it is singular that such a man should prove himself capable of such literary and historical knowledge, and of such artful cunning. If the stone be fraudulent, it seems necessary to suppose that a non-educated Swede should be able to make the inscription and to accomplish the following:

1. A simple, straightforward record.

2. Correct the prevalent notion as to the whereabouts of Vinland.

3. Refer to two skerries, which could not have existed when the record was made but did exist 548 years ago.

4. Refer to an island, which was not an island when the stone was inscribed, but was so 548 years ago.

5. Define exactly the location of the camp with reference to the seaside and with reference to the stone.

6. Describe the massacre in such a way as to indicate that the men were scalped by Indians, although no mention is made of Indians.

7. Make the prayer to the Virgin Mary common in Scandinavia in 1362, but anachronistic in the nineteenth century.

8. As an impostor, utter the common prayer of a devout Catholic of the fourteenth century. 254

9. Use in part some ancient runic characters instead of those common in later centuries.

10. All this deceit and laborious cunning, without any ascertainable motive, perpetrated in an unpopulated, or at most only a sparsely inhabited, region amongst a wilderness of forests. “

And finally

“Resolved , That this Committee renders a favorable opinion of the authenticity of the Kensington rune stone, provided, that the references to Scandinavian literature given in this Committee's written report and accompanying papers be verified by a competent specialist in the Scandinavian languages, to be selected by this Committee, and that he approve the conclusions of this report.”

The Wiki link has nothing new and I haven’t had time to wade through all the arguments on the Andy White link regarding the calcite weathering and speculating on the historical provenance and cleaning of KRS.


"The Stone Age did not end for lack of stone, and the Oil Age will end long before the world runs out of oil"

-- Sheikh Zaki Yamani
Subject Author Posted

Kensington Runestone Revisited

Hermione July 06, 2014 12:25PM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Khazar-khum July 06, 2014 03:20PM

Minnesota’s Runestone: Whose History Is It?

Hermione June 07, 2015 04:47PM

Minnesota County Building Visitor Center to Tell the Kensington Rune Stone Story (13 7 17)

Hermione July 13, 2017 10:44AM

Re: Minnesota County Building Visitor Center to Tell the Kensington Rune Stone Story (13 7 17)

Allan Shumaker July 13, 2017 11:04AM

Re: Minnesota County Building Visitor Center to Tell the Kensington Rune Stone Story (13 7 17)

Hermione July 13, 2017 12:07PM

Re: Minnesota County Building Visitor Center to Tell the Kensington Rune Stone Story (13 7 17)

Allan Shumaker July 13, 2017 06:10PM

Re: Minnesota County Building Visitor Center to Tell the Kensington Rune Stone Story (13 7 17)

Hermione July 14, 2017 06:38AM

Re: Minnesota County Building Visitor Center to Tell the Kensington Rune Stone Story (13 7 17)

Allan Shumaker July 14, 2017 02:34PM

Re: Minnesota County Building Visitor Center to Tell the Kensington Rune Stone Story (13 7 17)

Hermione July 15, 2017 04:55AM

More About Kensington Runestone

Paul H. July 19, 2017 02:33PM

Re: More About Kensington Runestone

Allan Shumaker July 19, 2017 05:07PM

Re: More About Kensington Runestone

Hermione July 21, 2017 07:35AM

Re: More About Kensington Runestone

Hermione July 22, 2017 04:20AM

Vikings in N. America

Hermione July 22, 2017 04:27AM

Re: Vikings in N. America

Allan Shumaker July 22, 2017 08:43AM

Re: Vikings in N. America

Hermione July 22, 2017 10:19AM

Re: More About Kensington Runestone

Hermione July 31, 2017 11:02AM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Allan Shumaker June 07, 2015 05:50PM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Khazar-khum June 07, 2015 08:26PM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Roxana Cooper June 09, 2015 07:24PM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Rick Baudé June 10, 2015 09:37AM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Khazar-khum June 10, 2015 05:34PM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Allan Shumaker June 10, 2015 07:10PM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Rick Baudé June 10, 2015 10:25PM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Roxana Cooper June 11, 2015 10:11AM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Jammer June 11, 2015 10:31AM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Rick Baudé June 11, 2015 02:41PM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Allan Shumaker June 11, 2015 03:29PM

Re: Been there, got the T-shirt, and now -

Khazar-khum June 11, 2015 04:34PM

Re: Kensington Runestone Revisited

Hermione August 02, 2017 02:05AM

Swedish Scholar Finds New Evidence that the Kensington Runestone Uses 19th Century Runes

Hermione November 29, 2017 06:17PM

Douglas County, Minnesota Opens Visitors Center to Promote Kensington Runestone

Hermione January 06, 2018 08:55AM

Re: Douglas County, Minnesota Opens Visitors Center to Promote Kensington Runestone

Hermione January 06, 2018 09:29AM

Re: Douglas County, Minnesota Opens Visitors Center to Promote Kensington Runestone

Khazar-khum January 07, 2018 01:57PM

Re: Douglas County, Minnesota Opens Visitors Center to Promote Kensington Runestone

Rick Baudé January 07, 2018 04:32PM

Re: Douglas County, Minnesota Opens Visitors Center to Promote Kensington Runestone

Hermione January 07, 2018 05:26PM

Re: Douglas County, Minnesota Opens Visitors Center to Promote Kensington Runestone

Khazar-khum January 08, 2018 07:39PM

Re: Douglas County, Minnesota Opens Visitors Center to Promote Kensington Runestone

Rick Baudé January 08, 2018 09:31PM

Re: Douglas County, Minnesota Opens Visitors Center to Promote Kensington Runestone

Khazar-khum January 09, 2018 08:02PM

Re: Douglas County, Minnesota Opens Visitors Center to Promote Kensington Runestone

Rick Baudé January 09, 2018 09:44PM

Re: Kensington Runestone Revisited

Hermione March 05, 2019 08:22AM

Re: Kensington Runestone Revisited

Allan Shumaker March 05, 2019 09:10AM

The Lost Templar Journals of Prince Henry Sinclair

Hermione March 05, 2019 09:18AM

Re: The Lost Templar Journals of Prince Henry Sinclair

Hans March 05, 2019 11:59AM

Re: The Lost Templar Journals of Prince Henry Sinclair

Allan Shumaker March 05, 2019 01:26PM

Re: The Lost Templar Journals of Prince Henry Sinclair

Hermione March 05, 2019 02:23PM

Re: The Lost Templar Journals of Prince Henry Sinclair

Allan Shumaker March 05, 2019 04:22PM

Re: Kensington Runestone Revisited

Hermione March 18, 2019 02:50PM

Re: Kensington Runestone Revisited

Lee Olsen March 18, 2019 03:49PM

A second Kensington Runestone ??

Hermione March 27, 2020 10:43AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login