Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

May 6, 2024, 2:29 am UTC    
August 24, 2001 11:07AM
<HTML>I see that Robert Bauval is shouting from teh rooftops about the support of astrophysicist <a href="[www.grahamhancock.com]
">Chandra Wickramsinghe</a> for the Orion Correlation Theory.

The respect shown to Chandra W.'s academic credentials (in astrophysics, NOT Archaeology or Ancient History) is sorely lacking when it comes to any credentialed ancient historians and Egyptologists (or anyone else) who challenge the ideas of RB, GH, or any of the alternative ilk. Rather, credentialed critics are dismissed, disparaged and abused as cretinous pedants by the entirely uncredentialed "alternative" novelists.

A test. What reaction, do you think Bauval would have had if Chandra W. disagreed with the OCT and published a criticism of it in a newspaper? Would he be shouting CW's eminence from the rooftops then? Inviting him along for the planned tour of Egypt?

To some, it might seem rather hypocritical to, on the one hand, roundly abuse academia in general and then, on the other, trumpet the credentials and professional eminence of any academic who happens to voice support.

Conclusion: "Alternative" authors are as selective in their presentation of academic support as they are in their presentation of evidence.

Garrett</HTML>
Subject Author Posted

Bauval and Chandra W

Garrett Fagan August 24, 2001 11:07AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

ISHMAEL August 24, 2001 11:45AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Mikey Brass August 24, 2001 01:29PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

jameske August 24, 2001 11:45AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Mikey Brass August 24, 2001 01:31PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

ISHMAEL August 24, 2001 01:47PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Garrett Fagan August 24, 2001 03:51PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

jameske August 24, 2001 09:46PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Mikey Brass August 25, 2001 02:56AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

jameske August 25, 2001 02:27PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Mikey Brass August 25, 2001 05:44PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Stephen Tonkin August 26, 2001 12:58AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Mikey Brass August 26, 2001 04:12AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Stephen Tonkin August 26, 2001 04:45AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Mikey Brass August 26, 2001 04:47AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Stephen Tonkin August 26, 2001 08:13AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Mikey Brass August 26, 2001 08:19AM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Garrett August 25, 2001 12:07PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

jameske August 25, 2001 02:25PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Garrett August 26, 2001 02:13PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

John Wall August 24, 2001 01:24PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Martin Stower August 24, 2001 03:04PM

Re: Bauval and Chandra W

Garrett Fagan August 24, 2001 03:54PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login