| November 16, 2026, 1:29 pm UTC |
![]() |
| In: The Hall of Maat > Humanities - Culture and Anthropology > Search - Culture and Anthropology |
| Goto:  Forum List • Create A New Profile • Log In |
Hi Waynw, > It may "suggest" but does not "prove" that it is > not reasonable to believe that the knowledge is > probable. I don't think anyone bothers with trying to prove whether beliefs in possibilities are probable. You or anyone else can believe whatever you like. If you want to discuss the probability of pi being in known in Egypt, you have to tby Joanne - Ancient History
Speaking of eBay, as we were a couple of days ago, I wondered if you'd seen this? Only one day left and no taker for a priceless treasure that is now available for purchase. I can't imagine why no one has bid yet...by Joanne - Paper Lens
And more importantly, people were living there at the time. They died with bread baking in the oven... It's their lamps, pots, and pans, scales at the door, and medicine chests that I found intriguing.by Joanne - Ancient History
From my link (scroll about half way down): "Plinian eruption - an extremely explosive eruption in which a steady, turbulent stream of fragmented magma and magmatic gas is released at a high velocity from a vent. This is one of the most violent and dangerous types of erruptions. Plinian eruptions are characterized by large volumes of pyroclastics and tall eruption columns. This type of eruby Joanne - Ancient History
I'm afraid Gillings sounds uncomfortably like Neugebauer in spots, and besides that, I think he's outdated now.by Joanne - Ancient History
C Wayne Taylor Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Hi again, > > The question in this thread is not whether a > particular "P" theory is plausible. It is whether > it is reasonable to believe that any "P" theory > could be plausible. It is; however, plausibility does not mean a theory is not objectionable. You stillby Joanne - Ancient History
Wayne, What suggests that the knowledge is not probable is that we have no evidence that it was known in Egypt, although we do have some math material from Egypt. You know the saying, "Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence," right? It's technically true, but it doesn't help resolve inconsistencies such as this pi problem. You cannot use the argument that theby Joanne - Ancient History
who and what are you answering?by Joanne - Ancient History
I see this as similar to the problem of alleged astronomical alignments. In the case of celestial texts, we may have more surviving than we have for math. People frequently theorize alignment theories that involve astronomy that is not attested in Egypt. I think Anthony is arguing for a parallel idea in the case of pyramid pi. If knowledge of pi is not attested in early Egypt, then theorizingby Joanne - Ancient History
Doesn't that suggest that they could have chosen an angle?by Joanne - Ancient History
I don't think they had experience with this type of volcano; nobody had. Anyway, the details of Roman life, what I started the thread to discuss, have been lost in the volcanic shuffle, so I'll bow out and leave you Vulcans to talk amongst yourselves....by Joanne - Ancient History
They may have known about earthquakes, but they hadn't seen an eruption TTBOMK, and if they had it wasn't like the one at Pompeii. Pliny died making a scientific investigation; apparently he was caught in the pyroclastic flow. They seem to have named that type of eruption after him...by Joanne - Ancient History
Anthony Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > C Wayne Taylor Wrote: > -------------------------------------------------- > ----- > > (deletions additions) > > > > > > Is the following a plausible argument? > > > > The errors in the argument have been shown > repeatedly. Your constant retyping of them wiby Joanne - Ancient History
The Dendera temple dates from Roman times; "us" is a Latin ending.by Joanne - Ancient History
Anthony Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > The concept of "squaring a circle" means creating > a square with the same perimeter as the diameter > of a circle. > > For example, if you had a circle with a diameter > of ten inches, you would have a circumference of > 31.4 inches. A square with this same diameter > would hby Joanne - Ancient History
C Wayne Taylor Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Hi Joanne, > > > > I don't know what other material you > are > > referring > > > to. > > > > The fact that we do not have evidence that > the AE > > knew pi for a fact. > > If we had the evidence to establish it as a fact, > the &qby Joanne - Ancient History
Linguistics is very much anthropology. I am not going to waste any more time trying to share information with you. You are convinced you know more about everything than anyone else on this board despite the fact that you know very little about anything.by Joanne - Ancient History
Jammer Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > > "We are taking Roman domestic life into a > more intellectual realm," Dr Allison said" > > I would point out Pompeii would be a snapshot of > domestic life in Pompeii, but far from > representative of every day life in everyday Roman > settlements... I think you are wrong aby Joanne - Ancient History
C Wayne Taylor Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Joanne Wrote: > > Yes, but making a case should include the > total > > evidence. One piece that is weak on its own > can > > add support when included with others. > > I think that stating "the slope matches pi" might > be begging the question. If it is tby Joanne - Ancient History
This is intriguing; I would love to see more studies like this. Pompeii is obviously unique for freezing a place in time, but I'm glad to see more and more interest in the daily life of ordinary people.by Joanne - Ancient History
If piling the stones on in courses is all that it takes to get a slope, why do different pyramids have different angles of slope?by Joanne - Ancient History
C Wayne Taylor Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Hi Joanne, > > > I think the slope itself is just as much a > piece > > of evidence that suggests they may have known > pi, > > I agree. But, I would consider it a weak piece of > evidence since the slope is also consistent with > an arguably standard seked. Yes, buby Joanne - Ancient History
Do you mean Harsomtus? In the PT, this is Har-mau, Horus the Uniter, according to Hart.by Joanne - Ancient History
Hi Wayne, > I think it is a piece of evidence that supports > the proposition that Egyptians had a realistic > potential to know "P". It indicates a later > awareness of and interest in the object of the > debate, thus adding to the likelihood of having > actually discovered "P". I think the slope itself is just as much a piece of evidence that suby Joanne - Ancient History
Anthony Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > This is absolutely key to the refutation of > Pyramid Pi. The first time we find ANY mention at > all of "an interest in circles", we find them > using something COMPLETELY DIFFERENT as a method > for the calculations. They use a square drawn > around the cirlce, with NO attempt at makiby Joanne - Ancient History
Hi Lee and Greg, Thank you both for your thoughts. The only other thing I can think of WRT completion or conclusion is that Egypt was the land the people finally reached (after traveling from where?), and decided to settle, or that the land was given to them in payment (by whom for what?). Both are based on pure speculation. I have no answer for Greg's question either, though itby Joanne - Ancient History
Hi Lee, Last time this question came up, I wondered about the possibility of km.t possibly originally meaning "place/land of the cattle count" or the "land/place of cattle counters." This takes "km" to mean "to total up," "to account," or "to complete." Furthermore, "the conclusion (of a book)" is a pun for "herd of cby Joanne - Ancient History