Henry was genuinely convinced he was cursed, how else to explain his failure to get a son? Obviously God was Angry! The problem with Henry was he had to feel justified always. He could have contested the validity of the dispensation on technical grounds, the phrasing was unclear, but instead he fixated on the most unacceptable grounds possible. He genuinely did believe in his pretext because it justified an act he also knew was caddish. He became furious when opposed because it challenged his self deception.
Catherine was equally committed to her course of action. She sincerely believed she was England's destined queen, to question that threatened her identity. She was in the right, yes, but by refusing to face the fact the breech went deeper than Henry's passion for a younger woman. The lack of a male heir was a genuine political problem which threatened the stability of the kingdom, even the independence of England. Other Queens had faced annulment. Jeanne de France was similarly victimized but unlike Catherine Jeanne eventually accepted defeat. Catherine of Aragon sacrificed the Church in England and the well-being of her daughter to her own 'rights'.
Forgive me, this is a subject I know a lot about.