Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

November 17, 2026, 5:40 pm UTC    
March 21, 2012 19:40PM
Gary Daniels Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Had I posted those same side by side comparisons,
> every debunker on this board would have screamed
> "they look NOTHING like the real dog you're
> comparing them to."
>
> In fact, my Bull Creek Dog Pot and Chihuahua photo
> are closer in appearance to each other than any of
> the dogs in your flikr example (except perhaps B-
> Xolo).
>
> Oh, and where's your citation that the tlachichi
> is the same as the techichi? Had I made such an
> unsubstantiated claim, you would have burst your
> appendix. Different rules?
>

It is interesting to see that people who push "alternative views," are contemptuous of the refereed literature, and cite primarily secondary or outdated sources, become hyperpunctilious about citations by their opponents. If you had been a longer participant in this group, you would know that I seldom venture and unsupported claim. If you had read my previous post [www.hallofmaat.com] more carefully, you would have seen my discussion of the absence of techichi in 16th century primary sources, i.e. Sahagun. It does seem to first appear in Clavijero (1615) and is then picked up in the key 19th century dictionary Simeon. Because of the identity in characteristics between the tlalchichi not tlachichi and the techichi (i.e small, eaten, buried with dead masters) and a known linguistic problem that Spanish had with the [tl] sound in Nahuatl (i.e. chocolatl=chocolate, tomatl=tomate;coyotl=coyote] I suggested that tlalchichi became techichi in Colonial times. I have written my friend Joe Campbell, a Nahuatl scholar at Indiana University, to check out the linguistics. However, there is a source for the identity of the techihi and tlalchichi:

Santamaria, F.J. 1974[1954] Diccionario de mejicanismos 2nd ed. Mexicotongue sticking out smileyorrua

p. 1021 [BOM my translation] Techichi (from Aztec tetl, stone and chichi, dog) noun. Name gives to a mute dog (Canis caribaeus, L.C. americanus). A native species found by the Spanish in the Antilles and in continental America as a valued domestic animal; edible, desired by the Aztecs, used as an adornment in Haiti, where it was called alco, as a current little dog among women, worshipped in Peru. After the conquest, the Spanish ate the flesh of this animal in such quantities that it was almost extinct. It is very rare to find. It is some 15 cm[6"] in height, thick body about 30 cm[12"] long, color dark lead almost black. Shiny thick, smooth skin with sporadic stuck bristles. It is very sensitive to cold. It is timid and emits a squeal very different from a dog bark. In Colombia and Venezuela it is called calungo. ROBELO 665 (TECHICHI: tetl, stone, chichi “stone dog” Because it was mute and had a melancholic aspect this dog seemed to be stone. A domestic quadruped that was entire mute— from which, according to Clavijero- the myth originated that European dogs taken to America became mute. The Mexicans fattened the techichi and ate it. When an owner died, the techichi was burned and buried with him. The Spaniards, after the conquest, before they had herds of any species of animal, used to provision their ships with the flesh of these quadrupeds and thus extinguished the species despite their being very numerous.

p. 1058 Tlalchichi (From the Azted tlalli, earth and chichi, little dog) Noun Aztequism used to designate the mute dog, or native dog, or dog from Chihuahua, which is a noteworthy race, or native variety of this country. Also TECHICHI

[BOM] Another source for the Robelo quote Robelo, C.A. n.d. [1912] Diccionario de Aztequismos or Garden of Aztec Roots. Words of the Nahuatl, Aztec, or Mexican language introduced into Spanish in various ways Mexico: Ediciones Fuente Cultural p. 468

Unfortunately, I'm leaving in a few hours to spend 3 weeks in Europe and will have to resume the discussion when I get back

Bernard



Subject Author Posted

Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels February 15, 2012 23:21PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Katherine Reece February 15, 2012 23:45PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels February 16, 2012 00:12AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Rick Baudé February 16, 2012 02:13AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

donald r raab February 19, 2012 00:18AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Katherine Reece February 19, 2012 01:28AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels March 20, 2012 23:16PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Katherine Reece March 20, 2012 23:31PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels March 20, 2012 23:40PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Roxana Cooper February 16, 2012 09:59AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels March 20, 2012 23:19PM

American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece February 16, 2012 10:48AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Khazar-khum February 18, 2012 04:57AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Lee Olsen February 18, 2012 06:40AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Khazar-khum February 18, 2012 15:21PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

donald r raab February 18, 2012 16:26PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece February 18, 2012 18:37PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Roxana Cooper February 18, 2012 19:34PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

donald r raab February 19, 2012 00:12AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Gary Daniels March 20, 2012 23:46PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

donald r raab March 22, 2012 10:26AM

Moderation Note

Katherine Reece March 22, 2012 11:08AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece February 18, 2012 11:19AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Khazar-khum February 18, 2012 15:20PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece February 18, 2012 18:34PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Khazar-khum February 18, 2012 20:42PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece February 19, 2012 01:24AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Khazar-khum February 19, 2012 01:57AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece February 19, 2012 02:11AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Gary Daniels March 20, 2012 23:34PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece March 21, 2012 00:24AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Gary Daniels March 21, 2012 09:31AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece March 21, 2012 12:12PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

donald r raab February 19, 2012 02:13AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece February 19, 2012 02:22AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

donald r raab February 19, 2012 02:26AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

bernard February 19, 2012 02:54AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

donald r raab February 19, 2012 07:51AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Lee Olsen February 19, 2012 08:05AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece February 19, 2012 11:53AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Allan Shumaker February 19, 2012 09:59AM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

donald r raab February 18, 2012 16:28PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Gary Daniels March 20, 2012 23:22PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Katherine Reece March 20, 2012 23:25PM

Re: American Dingo - Native American Dogs

Khazar-khum March 22, 2012 12:34PM

Ancient DNA Evidence for Old World Origin of New World Dogs

Katherine Reece February 19, 2012 12:32PM

Archaeology is going to the dogs

donald r raab February 19, 2012 14:48PM

Re: Archaeology is going to the dogs

Khazar-khum February 19, 2012 15:12PM

Re: Ancient DNA Evidence for Old World Origin of New World Dogs

Khazar-khum February 19, 2012 15:15PM

Re: Ancient DNA Evidence for Old World Origin of New World Dogs

donald r raab February 19, 2012 15:34PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

bernard February 21, 2012 02:55AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Khazar-khum February 21, 2012 11:25AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

bernard February 22, 2012 17:20PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Khazar-khum February 22, 2012 23:35PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels March 21, 2012 00:18AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

bernard March 21, 2012 19:40PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels March 21, 2012 00:05AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Katherine Reece March 21, 2012 00:32AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Rick Baudé March 21, 2012 11:32AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

bernard March 21, 2012 20:12PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels March 22, 2012 11:01AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Rick Baudé March 22, 2012 11:16AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels March 22, 2012 11:23AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Katherine Reece March 22, 2012 11:28AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels March 22, 2012 11:34AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Katherine Reece March 22, 2012 11:43AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Gary Daniels February 04, 2013 22:26PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Allan Shumaker February 05, 2013 09:30AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Khazar-khum February 05, 2013 13:11PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

bernard February 06, 2013 23:30PM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Hermione February 07, 2013 05:25AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

Lee Olsen February 07, 2013 08:06AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

bernard February 07, 2013 10:00AM

Re: Chihuahua pots in Georgia, 800 years old, suggest Mexican connection

G Horvat May 20, 2014 21:32PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login