Tommi Huhtamaki Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Is it really
> > that difficult a question to answer?
>
> I already answered, it wasn't diffucult at all. I
> said I didn't know. So what?
>
> You claim to know that it is a new species,
I don't know whether it's a new species or not. I'm saying that it's one possibility that can't be ruled out. Which is something that the Seth is a fantasy animal folk seem determined to do.
it's
> up to you to provide the evidence.
Sure I'd love to provide the evidence. A first step might be to collect all the various pictures and statues of Seth and then generate a computer composite of all these various portraitures of seth and then compare it to known animal species and then start to zero in on what family he might belong too. Again we might need to go to the paleontological record too and see if there's anything similar there. Something the "Seth is a fantasy" don't want to do or can't do.
I'd think the
> reason why people get irritated is that you accuse
> others of Brilliant Speculation, and then have
> nothing to offer but speculation yourself.
>
There's a difference. They offer their "brilliant speculation" as the defnitive statement on the subject. I'm saying that my "brilliant speculation" is a strong possibility that should be investigated.
> But have it which ever way you like. I know it's
> lack of detachment, but I'd really love it if it
> actually was a new species of animal that we have
> yet to find any physical evidence. But I'd need at
> least a tiniest shread of evidence to even
> entertain the thought for more than a minute.
>
>
That's great because we've got more than tiniest shred of evidence we have all these statues and images of Seth as a great starting point. So you can start entertaining that thought. That's the point I've been trying to make over and over again. I think there's a strong possibility that it's a new species of animal. For instance the 'tasmanian devil' is officially extinct but there's still sighting all the time of it. The Coelacanths vanished totally from the fossil record iirc for sixty million years. It was considered to be absolutely extinct. There wasn't one shred of evidence to suppport their existence. None, zero, nada, zilch, zippo. Anybody who proposed that their were living coelacanths would have been laughed out of the room. And then it was found alive in various parts of the world. I subscribe to Science News among other magazines and new species of mammals are being discovered all the time all over the world. Maybe it's extinct, maybe it isn't but until we get out and start looking who will know. But one more time (as the coelacanth's should tell you.) absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence.
>
>
>
> "Guns don't kill people, physics kills people."
> -Dr. Dick Solomon
>
>
>
> Edited 1 times. Last edit at 05/20/07 12:33PM by
> .