Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

November 17, 2026, 7:42 am UTC    
May 17, 2007 18:49PM
Joanne Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Rick Baudé Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
>
> > I wasn't arguing by assertion. I was
> collecting
> > the evidence that has been preserved us by
> the
> > AE's if you choose to ignore
> it/disregard/dismiss
> > it that's your problem not mine
>
> Rick, I have not seen you present any images of
> the so-called Seth animal that is not an image of
> Seth himself. Do you have an image of the animal
> that is not Seth? If so, post it and the source,
> because I have not seen it yet.
>

I presented 3 images of the seth animal. That's it. One with his head on a human body, 2 in his full form that should be instantly recognrizable to anybody's who's the least bit familiar with egyptology.

> > > However,none of this addresses my
> point,
> > which you
> > > have continued to duck, which is that
> there
> > are
> > > apparently no images anywhere of Seth
> > animals.
> >
> > I'm not ducking it. YOU"RE DISMISSING THE
> EVIDENCE
> > I'VE PRESENTED. PERIOD>
>
> Where have you presented this evidence, Rick? I
> have seen only images of Seth. Please post the
> links to the images of the creatures themselves,
> apart from Seth.

Uh the pictures I presented them before.

>
> > > You make no distinction between images
> of
> > Seth as
> > > the Seth animal and the alleged animals
> > > themselves.
> >
> > That's because there is no distinction. Nice
> > strawman argument though.
>
> Of course there is a distinction; we have images
> of all other cult animals AS animals. We have
> scenes showing pets, farm animals, sacrificial
> slaughter, hunting, even cartoons with cats
> waiting on mice. Where are the images of Seth
> animals APART from Seth himself?
>
> What you have shown are images of the god, who was
> depicted as a composite, imaginary creature. Show
> me a pack of these creatures hunting, show me a
> herd of them grazing, show one kept as a pet.
> That's all I'm asking. Just one image from
> anytime in a 3000 year period.

Oh please. You must be joking. This a classic case "absence of evidence is evidence of absence". Sure I'll show you the pix write after you show me a pix of that imaginary architect Imhotep designing a pyramid. Nice try I've shown you three there must be hundreds more images of Seth. It's your turn to do a google search.
>
> Btw, a strawman argument mischaracterizes the
> opponent's argument and argues against the
> mischaracterized view rather than the actual view.
> I have not done that anywhere in this thread. The
> fact that someone disagrees with you does make
> that person automatically guilty of a fallacy.
>


> > Like I said, trying to draw an analogy with
> the
> > owls, so I'll try again. Owls must have
> been
> > important because we have thousands of pixs
> of
> > owls, we know the species of the owl. But
> show me
> > one pix of the owl in its natural
> enviornment.
> > But what is the word for "owl" in Egypt?
> Nobody
> > knows, there's only been one owl mummy
> discovered
> > and that was intrusive. So using your logic
> we can
> > clearly we can say that there were no owls or
> only
> > one owl in Egypt.
>
> It's no analogy because again, I am NOT asking for
> a mummy! I asked you for evidence in the form of
> an image of the creature separate from the god.

Uhm yes in previous post you said if there was a seth animal where are the seth mummies? I'm saying with all the millions of owls painted, where were all the owl mummies. There aren't any. (except for one intrusive one that might have been shoved in there by a tourist.) So if for some reason if owls had gone into complete and total extinction we would, using your logic, be forced to conclude that owls were a fantastic creature.
>
>
> So what we've got dozens of
> > pictures of people, animals and flowers that
> we
> > know are real. So we know that they could
> portray
> > just about any realistic thing they wanted
> too.
>
> Right, but we have no images of any so-called Seth
> animals. Meanwhile, we have images of fabulous
> mythic beasts who are shown as specific deities,
> such as Seth or Ammut. Since we know something
> about the Egyptians' habits in depicting both
> their realistic world and their fantastic world,
> and since we have no images of the so-called Seth
> animal that is not Seth himself, we are led to one
> conclusion: the Seth animal was a particular image
> of an imaginary creature that was used to depict
> Seth.
>
>

Dazzling display of circular reasoning; The AE's made fabulous beasts that are imaginary. The seth animal is a fabulous beast. conclusion the seth animal is imaginary.


Rick
Subject Author Posted

Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 13, 2007 18:08PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 13, 2007 18:41PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 13, 2007 18:50PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 13, 2007 18:59PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 13, 2007 19:17PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 13, 2007 19:37PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ken B May 13, 2007 19:23PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 13, 2007 19:30PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 13, 2007 19:38PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 13, 2007 20:40PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 05:34AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Katherine Griffis-Greenberg May 14, 2007 07:15AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 14, 2007 08:06AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 09:51AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 14, 2007 09:57AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 14, 2007 10:31AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 14, 2007 13:21PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 10:52AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 14, 2007 13:08PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 13:22PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 14, 2007 13:41PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 14:03PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 16, 2007 10:21AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 16, 2007 16:16PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 17, 2007 09:41AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 17, 2007 10:27AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 17, 2007 12:08PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 17, 2007 13:22PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 17, 2007 14:29PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 17, 2007 14:45PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Katherine Griffis-Greenberg May 15, 2007 17:59PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 15, 2007 18:55PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 15, 2007 21:10PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 15, 2007 22:53PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 16, 2007 05:44AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 16, 2007 09:58AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 10:43AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 10:49AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 11:07AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

rich May 14, 2007 11:22AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 11:28AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 11:37AM

Serval

Greg Reeder May 14, 2007 12:38PM

Re: Serval

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 12:39PM

Re: Serval

Greg Reeder May 14, 2007 13:21PM

Re: Serval

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 13:40PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 14, 2007 12:28PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 13:28PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 13:50PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 14:10PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 14:53PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 16:14PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 16:56PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 18:47PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 19:19PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 14, 2007 20:23PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 22:29PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 15, 2007 10:44AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 16, 2007 18:13PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 17, 2007 09:45AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 17, 2007 18:27PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 17, 2007 10:52AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 17, 2007 18:49PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 17, 2007 19:15PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 17, 2007 19:43PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 17, 2007 22:07PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 17, 2007 23:22PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 18, 2007 07:09AM

Request ...

Hermione May 18, 2007 07:27AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

cicely May 17, 2007 22:26PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 17, 2007 22:49PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 17, 2007 22:54PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 17, 2007 23:21PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 17, 2007 23:36PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 18, 2007 07:52AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 19, 2007 09:10AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 19, 2007 12:17PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 19, 2007 12:45PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 19, 2007 12:54PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 19, 2007 13:04PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Tommi Huhtamaki May 19, 2007 15:42PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 19, 2007 16:42PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Tommi Huhtamaki May 19, 2007 16:46PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 19, 2007 16:52PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Tommi Huhtamaki May 19, 2007 17:01PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 19, 2007 17:09PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Tommi Huhtamaki May 19, 2007 17:15PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 19, 2007 18:02PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Tommi Huhtamaki May 20, 2007 15:57PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 21, 2007 20:00PM

Moderator Note

Katherine Reece May 18, 2007 16:54PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Katherine Griffis-Greenberg May 15, 2007 19:21PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 16, 2007 08:31AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Katherine Griffis-Greenberg May 16, 2007 13:31PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 16, 2007 16:20PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 16, 2007 19:35PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 16, 2007 10:08AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Pete Clarke May 17, 2007 07:32AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Ritva Kurittu May 17, 2007 09:48AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 12:11PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Don Barone May 14, 2007 12:24PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Rick Baudé May 14, 2007 12:29PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

rich May 14, 2007 12:27PM

Getting to where I am going with this

Don Barone May 14, 2007 14:22PM

Re: Getting to where I am going with this

Joanne May 14, 2007 15:58PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

rich May 14, 2007 15:18PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

rich May 16, 2007 09:03AM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Joanne May 16, 2007 16:23PM

Re: Orycteropus

Jaq White May 17, 2007 04:40AM

Re: Orycteropus

Ritva Kurittu May 17, 2007 09:53AM

The cat as a heirogplyph

Don Barone May 17, 2007 06:50AM

Re: The cat as a heirogplyph

Ritva Kurittu May 17, 2007 09:55AM

Re: The cat as a heirogplyph

Don Barone May 17, 2007 10:12AM

Re: The cat as a heirogplyph

Joanne May 17, 2007 11:00AM

Re: The cat as a heirogplyph

Don Barone May 17, 2007 11:37AM

Re: The cat as a heirogplyph

Joanne May 17, 2007 12:04PM

Re: The cat as a heirogplyph

Ritva Kurittu May 17, 2007 12:23PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Alcibiades June 14, 2007 13:29PM

Re: Apophis: Who was he and who was the rabbit that killed him ?

Katherine Reece June 14, 2007 13:54PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login