Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

November 16, 2026, 1:37 pm UTC    
April 29, 2007 11:57AM
Hi Ritva,


> Exactly!
> We see the opposites in back and white, whereas
> the Egyptians saw the polarity in red and white,
> but paralleled red to yellow and black to green!

And the black and green is not a minor point; this is explains the Black land as the (green) fertile land.

> The idea behind the use of a certain colour
> differs from ours… totally.

Red has good and bad connotations, remember the "Sethian" red. Also, as I mentioned above, in many languages, words can indicate colors that we would distinguish in English. This does not mean that the people did not see the colors as we do. It's simply the different ways different languages work. Egyptian does not have all the words we have for colors, and it also made some distinctions we do not make.

This becomes blatantly
> clear by simply looking at the hieroglyphs and how
> they were coloured: each glyph had it’s own
> colour. For example the sickle was coloured green,
> probably because it was made of wood and hence
> used to have green leaves. Glyphs representing
> objects of clay were coloured blue like the wet
> clay they were originally made of. Whereas we
> would colour all of those items brown.
> In other words, the ancient Egyptians’ conception
> of an object and it’s colour went further back
> than meets the eye and hence carried with it an
> entire conception not visible on the surface of
> the subject itself. Avry has written an excellent
> article, Out of the Green Sahara, about the hAst,
> axt and dw glyphs tracing the origin of the
> colours used and looking into the original idea
> behind those glyphs, and goes a long way to show
> that colour is not just colour as we understand
> it.

Where is Avry's article?

> Now, this invisible concept behind the colour must
> also extend itself to the way the Egyptians
> pictured themselves and how they pictured their
> own country. Not only in their own eyes, but how
> they represented it to the surrounding cultures
> i.e. how they called their own land. Otherwise we
> are taking things out of their own context to
> satisfy own needs (whatever those may be).
> Two very obvious things spring to mind directly.
> The first is the way the Egyptians “coloured”
> themselves: the men were red and the women were
> yellow. I don’t for one second agree with the
> Egyptologists about this reflecting the men having
> been outdoors more than the women. I personally
> think this refers to strength and beauty, but
> that’s another discussion. Why then would people
> picturing themselves as red and yellow call
> themselves the black people?

They wouldn't and they didn't. The colors they used to represent themselves probably do have meanings besides women being indoors more, I agree.

> The second is the way they distinguished
> themselves from their neighbors and to their
> neighbors. Did they sail to Punt and say: “Hi, we
> are The Black People” just to hear the queen of
> Punt answer: “Heck, so are we!” Not a fine way to
> distinguish one’s own land, is it? But saying that
> we are the people of the Black Land, would be
> different, because they had something most of
> their neighbors didn’t: the fertile Nile Valley
> with the black silt!

Most important IMO is the place determinative used with Km.t because that shows they intended to refer to themselves based on where they lived, not based on what they looked like.

> Going back to the idea behind the colour and
> looking at their way of linking the conception of
> origin to the colours used, isn’t it true that
> Egypt only existed as it did due to the Nile
> Valley and the yearly inundation? The famous
> inundation bringing in the silt and colouring the
> valley black? The very origin of Egypt. This
> doesn't mean I'd dispute "kmt" meaning balck. It
> certainly did, but what did the word mean to the
> Egyptians is another story, one that those
> claiming "kmt" to mean Land of Black People
> obviously have not read.

Personally, I still wonder if the original meaning didn't have some connection to the place of cattle counting or tallying up, though that seems to be a bit of stretch. It's interesting the "Egypt" comes for the name for Memphis, just one city. And that the determinative for Km.t is a village. Was the country named for one town, the place where some final account was made every couple of years?

> OK, all this written I have to make something
> quite clear: I don’t personally give a rat’s
> behind about the colour of the ancient Egyptians.
> They could have been black, white, red, yellow or
> even green with polkadots (that would have been
> cool!) for all I care, because the colour of their
> skin does not change the magnificent culture they
> had. But I have to say, that to twist the meaning
> of their words and ideas behind those words,
> taking them completely out of context and making
> them serve agendas they don’t belong to is plain
> silly. And saying that I have put it mildly.

Exactly

>
> Oh, I forgot. here's a little Sunday morning
> entertainment about changing history. Horus hawk
> and all!

That's awful; I kept waiting for the cigarette brand, the after shave lotion brand, the mouthwash brand, etc. to be revealed but it never was... I'm Outta Here!
Subject Author Posted

rmT.t

Lee April 24, 2007 09:51AM

Re: rmT.t

Ritva Kurittu April 24, 2007 09:59AM

Re: rmT.t

Lee April 24, 2007 10:35AM

Re: rmT.t

legeonas April 24, 2007 11:25AM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 24, 2007 13:13PM

Re: rmT.t

Greg Reeder April 24, 2007 13:27PM

Re: rmT.t

Lee April 24, 2007 13:59PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 24, 2007 14:30PM

Re: rmT.t

Doug M April 24, 2007 19:08PM

Re: rmT.t

legeonas April 25, 2007 00:39AM

Re: rmT.t

Doug M April 25, 2007 06:13AM

Re: rmT.t

legeonas April 25, 2007 07:15AM

Re: rmT.t

Lee April 25, 2007 11:23AM

Re: rmT.t

Doug M April 25, 2007 13:15PM

Subthread closed

Hermione April 25, 2007 14:05PM

Re: rmT.t

Principia April 27, 2007 23:21PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 28, 2007 09:42AM

Re: rmT.t

Ritva Kurittu April 28, 2007 14:00PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 28, 2007 18:18PM

Re: rmT.t

Ritva Kurittu April 29, 2007 04:50AM

Re: rmT.t

Hermione April 29, 2007 05:32AM

Re: rmT.t

broko April 29, 2007 09:53AM

Re: rmT.t

Ritva Kurittu April 29, 2007 11:06AM

Re: rmT.t

broko April 29, 2007 14:57PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 29, 2007 15:05PM

Re: rmT.t

broko April 29, 2007 15:12PM

Re: rmT.t

broko April 29, 2007 15:27PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 29, 2007 16:08PM

Re: rmT.t

Ritva Kurittu April 29, 2007 15:43PM

Re: rmT.t

broko April 29, 2007 16:01PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 29, 2007 16:14PM

Re: rmT.t

Ritva Kurittu April 29, 2007 16:14PM

Re: rmT.t

broko April 29, 2007 21:15PM

Re: rmT.t

legeonas May 01, 2007 17:17PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 29, 2007 11:57AM

Re: rmT.t

Tommi Huhtamaki April 29, 2007 12:10PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 29, 2007 15:20PM

Re: rmT.t

Tommi Huhtamaki April 29, 2007 15:40PM

Re: rmT.t

Tommi Huhtamaki April 29, 2007 15:56PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 29, 2007 16:01PM

Re: rmT.t

Tommi Huhtamaki April 29, 2007 16:17PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 29, 2007 16:51PM

Re: rmT.t

Doug M April 29, 2007 18:17PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 29, 2007 18:36PM

Re: rmT.t

Doug M April 29, 2007 18:58PM

Re: rmT.t

Joanne April 29, 2007 19:12PM

Re: rmT.t

Doug M April 29, 2007 20:09PM

Re: rmT.t

Sue April 30, 2007 11:17AM

Re: rmT.t

legeonas April 28, 2007 19:00PM

Request

Hermione April 25, 2007 09:56AM

Re: rmT.t

legeonas April 25, 2007 07:12AM

Re: rmT.t

broko April 29, 2007 10:06AM

Re: rmT.t

broko April 29, 2007 10:20AM

Re: rmT.t

Hermione April 29, 2007 10:49AM

Re: rmT.t

Lee April 29, 2007 12:14PM

Re: rmT.t

broko April 29, 2007 15:05PM

Moderaton Note

Katherine Reece April 29, 2007 15:32PM

Further moderation note

Katherine Reece April 29, 2007 16:00PM

Re: Further moderation note

broko April 29, 2007 16:06PM

Re: Further moderation note

Katherine Reece April 29, 2007 16:11PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login