Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors
Web Links

April 16, 2024, 8:57 am UTC    
December 06, 2021 01:21PM
I am going to break this up into several sections to address the issues I think I see. You may choose if you like to address only certain issues that you think are truly valid or ignore the whole thing... I hold no stakes in this and am simply explaining what I found problematic. Others will have different opinions.


Item 1: Introduction --I think the opening needs to focus more on your thesis statement. For example:

-------------------------------------------------------
engbren Wrote:

>> There is a rich archaeological record that demonstrates Babylonian astronomers kept detailed records of their observations of the
>> planets in Astronomical Diaries and Excerpt texts. Through observations of the planetary phenomena, Babylonian astronomers
>> developed mathematical models for predicting the timing of synodic phenomena and the synodic arc in the decades that followed
>> 400 BCE. Underpinning these mathematical models are two core algorithms for modelling periodic processes known as System A
>> and System B.

Your topic is Egyptian mathematics as a contribution to astronomy ... but it's not even mentioned in the first paragraph, where you go leaping right into the Babylonians. You should be talking about Egyptian astronomy and Egyptian math and making it very clear what time frame you're talking about (New Kingdom, Ptolemaic...whenever)

Also, you don't indicate where the Introduction ends... the paper is apparently one long introduction and a conclusion? There's no subtitles.

And is Chart 1 missing ("generating what is known as a zig zag function (refer example in Chart 1.)")? I see a Chart 2. No chart of zigzag function.

You mention a "System A" ("System A and System B") but you never explain what System A is and a search on Google doesn't turn up any explanation of what a System A is. Evidence should follow the "Checkov's Gun" rule... if you present a gun (a term or object) then it needs to be established in the beginning and used in a later part. You've shown us the "gun" called System A... but never explain why it's useful/interesting/necessary/needs to be talked about. If you don't use it, edit it out.

-- Byrd
Moderator, Hall of Ma'at
Subject Author Posted

Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren December 03, 2021 07:06PM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Byrd December 04, 2021 11:28PM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Hermione December 05, 2021 05:05AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren December 06, 2021 01:05AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Byrd December 06, 2021 01:21PM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren December 07, 2021 05:22AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Byrd December 06, 2021 03:15PM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren December 07, 2021 05:53AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren August 18, 2022 03:13AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren September 05, 2022 03:54AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Byrd September 06, 2022 09:23PM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Hermione September 07, 2022 10:17AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren September 08, 2022 02:58AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Byrd September 08, 2022 08:40PM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren September 09, 2022 03:03AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Hermione September 09, 2022 08:37AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Hermione September 10, 2022 01:50AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren September 10, 2022 05:14AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Byrd September 10, 2022 06:06PM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren September 14, 2022 07:18AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren October 25, 2022 06:24AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren December 07, 2023 07:37AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

Hermione December 07, 2023 10:26AM

Re: Egyptian contribution to mathematical astronomy

engbren December 11, 2023 05:24AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login