engbren Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I received some feedback from a highly respected
> academic that they felt my paper had several
> problems, including:
> 1. The core idea itself is very old and harks back
> to the ideas of Taylor and Piazzi Smyth;
> 2. The numbers as presented were very much skewed
> in favour of the design model; and
> 3. The presentation was confusing.

Where do Taylor and Piazzi Smyth talk about Saturn?

Hail Atlantis.